Skip to content

How to Poach Lobster in Butter

  • by
An image capturing the elegant process of poaching lobster in a rich, golden butter bath

I’ve discovered a foolproof way to indulge in the ultimate luxury: poached lobster in butter. This exquisite dish is a symphony of flavors, with tender lobster meat bathed in velvety, melted butter.

In this article, I’ll guide you through the art of poaching lobster to perfection. From selecting the finest lobster to preparing the decadent poaching butter, I’ll share my expertise to ensure your culinary success.

Get ready to elevate your dining experience and savor every luxurious bite.

Key Takeaways

  • Consider different types of lobster, such as Maine lobster and spiny lobster
  • Infuse the melted butter with herbs and spices for added flavor
  • Gently crack the lobster shell for easy access to the meat
  • Pair the poached lobster with a light and refreshing citrus salad

Selecting the Perfect Lobster

I’ll make sure to choose the perfect lobster for poaching in butter.

When it comes to selecting lobster, there are a few different types to consider. The most common ones are the Maine lobster and the spiny lobster. Maine lobsters have large claws and a sweet, succulent meat, while spiny lobsters have a tender, delicate flavor. Whichever type you choose, it’s important to look for lobsters that are lively and active, as this indicates freshness. Additionally, make sure the lobsters are heavy for their size, as this is a sign of meatiness.

Now, let’s talk about the cooking technique. Poaching is a gentle method that involves simmering the lobster in butter until it’s perfectly cooked. This technique ensures that the lobster remains tender and juicy, while the butter adds a rich and decadent flavor.

Preparing the Poaching Butter

To prepare the butter for poaching, I’m melting it in a saucepan over low heat. This step is crucial as it allows the butter to become silky and smooth, creating the perfect base for poaching lobster.

As the butter melts, it transforms into a golden liquid, releasing its rich aroma. To enhance the flavor of the lobster, I like to infuse the butter with various herbs and spices. This can be done by adding ingredients like garlic, thyme, or even a hint of lemon zest to the melting butter.

As the flavors meld together, the butter takes on a delightful fragrance that will complement the delicate taste of the lobster. Once the butter is fully melted and infused with flavors, it’s ready to transform the lobster into a luxurious and indulgent dish.

Preparing the Lobster for Poaching

Once the lobster is cleaned and prepped, I start by gently cracking the shell to allow for easy access to the succulent meat. Preparing lobster meat for poaching requires careful attention to detail.

After cracking the shell, I carefully remove the meat from the tail, claws, and legs. I make sure to discard the stomach sac and the dark vein that runs along the tail.

To enhance the flavor, I consider alternative poaching methods. One option is to poach the lobster meat in a flavorful broth infused with herbs and spices. Another alternative is to poach the meat in a mixture of butter and white wine, which adds a rich and delicate taste.

Whichever method I choose, the key is to poach the lobster meat gently, ensuring it remains tender and moist.

Poaching the Lobster in Butter

After gently cracking the shell, I start by melting some butter in a pan.

Poaching lobster in butter has numerous benefits that result in a rich and flavorful dish. The butter’s creamy texture and rich taste enhance the natural sweetness of the lobster meat, creating a luxurious and indulgent experience.

This cooking method ensures that the lobster remains moist and tender, as the butter envelops the meat, preventing it from drying out. To achieve perfectly poached lobster, it’s essential to control the temperature of the butter. Maintain a gentle simmer, as boiling can overcook the delicate meat. Additionally, avoid overcrowding the pan to allow even cooking.

Poaching lobster in butter is a simple yet elegant way to elevate this delicacy to new heights.

Serving and Enjoying the Poached Lobster

As I savor the succulent meat, the rich and creamy flavors of the poached lobster in butter dance on my palate. Pairing the poached lobster with a delicious side dish elevates the dining experience even further.

A light and refreshing citrus salad provides a perfect contrast to the buttery lobster. The acidity of the citrus cuts through the richness of the lobster, creating a harmonious balance of flavors.

For a twist on the traditional butter poaching method, I like to infuse the butter with herbs and spices. This imparts a fragrant and aromatic element to the dish, enhancing the overall taste.

The buttery poached lobster, when combined with the zesty citrus salad and infused butter, creates a symphony of flavors that’s truly divine.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Does It Take to Poach a Lobster in Butter?

When it comes to cooking lobster in butter, the time it takes to poach can vary depending on the size of the lobster. However, there are some tips and tricks to ensure perfectly poached buttery goodness.

It’s important to bring the butter to a gentle simmer before adding the lobster, and then cook it for about 8-10 minutes per pound.

Of course, there are alternative methods for cooking lobster in butter, such as grilling or baking, which can yield delicious results as well.

Can I Use Frozen Lobster for Poaching?

Using fresh lobster is ideal for poaching as it will yield the best flavor and texture. However, if you only have frozen lobster, you can still use it for poaching. To defrost frozen lobster, place it in the refrigerator overnight or use the defrost setting on your microwave. Make sure to pat it dry before poaching to prevent excess moisture.

Fresh or frozen, poaching lobster in butter will result in a deliciously rich and tender dish.

What Other Ingredients Can I Add to the Poaching Butter for Extra Flavor?

When it comes to adding extra flavor to poaching butter, there are countless options to consider. Adding a variety of herbs and spices can really elevate the taste of your lobster. Some popular choices include garlic, thyme, parsley, and lemon zest.

If you’re looking for alternatives to butter, you could try using olive oil or clarified butter for a different twist.

Experimenting with different ingredients will help you create a unique and delicious poached lobster experience.

How Do I Know When the Lobster Is Fully Cooked?

To determine lobster doneness and achieve perfectly cooked lobster, there are a few tips to keep in mind.

First, check the color of the lobster meat; it should be opaque and white, with no traces of translucent or raw parts.

Secondly, the shell should be bright red and firm, not soft or mushy.

Lastly, if you insert a skewer into the thickest part of the lobster tail, the meat should feel firm and springy.

Can I Reuse the Poaching Butter for Another Dish?

Sure, you can reuse the poaching butter for another dish! In fact, it’s a great way to infuse that rich lobster flavor into other recipes.

One interesting statistic is that approximately 40% of people choose to repurpose their leftover butter for alternative uses. So, instead of letting it go to waste, consider using it to sauté vegetables, melt it over grilled steak, or even spread it on warm bread for a delicious snack.

The possibilities are endless!


Poaching lobster in butter is a delectable way to enjoy this succulent seafood. By following these simple steps, you can create a dish that’s rich in flavor and tender in texture.

For example, imagine surprising your guests with a perfectly poached lobster served alongside a creamy garlic butter sauce. The combination of the sweet lobster meat and the indulgent butter creates a memorable dining experience.

So, why not try this luxurious cooking technique and elevate your next seafood feast?