If you’re searching for a reliable bread and butter pickle recipe, you’re likely weighing homemade methods against ready-made mixes. The Amish Wedding Foods All Natural Bread N Butter Pickles stand out for their fresh, all-natural flavor, making them the top overall choice. For those who prefer convenience, the Mrs. Wages Bread and Butter Pickle Mix offers quick results with consistent taste, and the Bubbies Pickles Variety Pack appeals to those seeking variety and versatility. Each approach has tradeoffs—homemade recipes require time and skill, while mixes prioritize speed but may sacrifice some flavor depth. Continue reading for a detailed breakdown of these options and more to find your perfect bread and butter pickle solution.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
- The top picks balance flavor authenticity with ease of use, favoring natural ingredients and straightforward preparation.
- Pre-made mixes provide quick results but may lack the depth of flavor found in homemade or slow-cooked recipes.
- Jar size and packaging matter—larger quantities can save money but might be less convenient for small households.
- Additional options like variety packs expand choice but often come at a higher price per jar.
- Ingredient quality and preservative content are key factors that set apart premium options from budget choices.
| Amish Wedding Foods All Natural Bread N Butter Pickles, 32 Ounces (Pack of 2) |  | Best Overall for Natural, Large-Scale Use | Weight: 32 ounces per jar | Quantity: 2 jars | Type: Bread and butter pickles | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Amish Wedding Zesty Bread & Butter Pickles, 32 Ounce Jar |  | Best for Zesty, Spicy Flavor Enthusiasts | Weight: 32 oz | Made in: USA | Ingredients: cucumbers, onions, sugar, vinegar, salt, spices, hot peppers | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Amish Wedding Foods Bread & Butter Pickles, 2 x 32 oz. Quart Jars (Zesty) |  | Best for Traditional Amish Zesty Flavors in Bulk | Quantity: 2 jars | Size: 32 oz. each | Flavor: Zesty Amish-style | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Amish Valley Products Bread and Butter Pickles – 32 oz Glass Jar |  | Best for Classic, Slightly Sweet Pickles with No Preservatives | Weight: 32 oz | Container: Glass jar | Flavor: Sweet and tangy | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Amish Wedding Foods Bread & Butter Pickles, 2 x 32 oz. Quart Jars |  | Best for Traditional Amish Quality in Small Batches | Size: 2 x 32 oz. jars | Made in: Holmes County, Ohio | Flavor: Classic bread and butter | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Bubbies Pickles Variety Pack – 32 oz Bread & Butter, 32 oz Dill, 25 oz Sauerkraut |  | Best for Gut Health and Versatility | Product Type: Variety Pack | Contents: Bread & Butter, Dill, Sauerkraut | Fermentation: Naturally fermented | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Mrs. Wages Bread and Butter Pickle Mix 5.3 oz |  | Best for Small Batches and Ease of Use | Package Size: 5.3 oz | Yield: Small batch | Includes: Dry pickle mix | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Mrs. Wages Bread and Butter Pickles Quick Process Mix, 6 Pack (5.3 oz each) |  | Best for Large Batches and Convenience | Quantity: 6 pouches | Weight per pouch: 5.3 oz | Yield: 7 quarts per pouch | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Amish Wedding Foods All Natural Bread N Butter Pickles, 32 Ounces (Pack of 2)
This product stands out for its commitment to all-natural ingredients and generous pack size, making it ideal for those who want versatile, homemade-style bread and butter pickles in bulk. Compared to the Zesty Amish Wedding pickles, these are milder and less spicy, which appeals to a broader audience but may lack the punch spice lovers crave. The large 32-ounce jars are perfect for family-sized portions or frequent use, though the label provides limited details about sugar content—something to consider if you’re watching your intake. Their sweet and tangy flavor makes them ideal for sandwiches, salads, or snacking. However, the absence of detailed product info and potential high sugar levels could be drawbacks for health-conscious buyers. Choose this if you want natural ingredients and a big supply of classic bread and butter pickles.
Pros:- All-natural ingredients ensure no artificial additives
- Large pack size offers great value for frequent use
- Sweet and tangy flavor versatile for many dishes
Cons:- Limited product description details
- Potentially high in sugar, which may concern health-focused buyers
Best for: Families or home cooks looking for a large quantity of all-natural bread and butter pickles for everyday use.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking low-sugar or diet-specific options, or those wanting detailed nutritional info.
- Weight:32 ounces per jar
- Quantity:2 jars
- Type:Bread and butter pickles
- Ingredients:All natural
Our verdict“This pick is best for those who want a natural, budget-friendly bulk option for everyday bread and butter pickles.”
Amish Wedding Zesty Bread & Butter Pickles, 32 Ounce Jar
This option is perfect for those who enjoy a tangy, spicy kick, especially if you like hot peppers in your pickles. When compared to the milder Amish Wedding pickles, the addition of hot peppers makes these notably more flavorful and lively, though that also means they may be too fiery for sensitive palates. Packaged in a glass jar, they promise freshness and a more authentic homemade feel. These pickles excel as a condiment or topping for burgers and sandwiches, bringing a zesty punch to every bite. However, the spicy element limits appeal for those who prefer traditional sweet bread and butter flavors or have dietary restrictions regarding heat. This pick makes sense for spice lovers wanting a flavorful twist on classic pickles.
Pros:- Made locally in Ohio supports regional producers
- Flavorful and zesty with a spicy kick
- Packaged in a glass jar for freshness
Cons:- Contains hot peppers, which may be too spicy for some
- Limited to those who enjoy spicy pickles
Best for: Spice enthusiasts or home cooks who want a zesty, hot version of bread and butter pickles to elevate meals.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer classic sweet and tangy pickles without heat or those sensitive to spice.
- Weight:32 oz
- Made in:USA
- Ingredients:cucumbers, onions, sugar, vinegar, salt, spices, hot peppers
Our verdict“This pick is ideal for those craving a bold, spicy twist on traditional bread and butter pickles.”
Amish Wedding Foods Bread & Butter Pickles, 2 x 32 oz. Quart Jars (Zesty)
This product is crafted from traditional Amish recipes, making it a solid choice for those who appreciate authentic, small-batch pickles with a zesty edge. Compared with the all-natural Amish Wedding pickles, this version emphasizes a more pronounced zest, appealing to those who prefer bolder flavors. The large 32 oz. jars are convenient for frequent use or for serving at gatherings. While the all-natural aspect is a plus, the intense zesty flavor might be overwhelming for some, especially if you prefer milder bread and butter varieties. The lack of specific dietary info means it may not suit all health needs. This pick is best for traditionalists who enjoy a robust, Amish-style zesty pickle.
Pros:- Made from traditional Amish recipes
- Small-batch, authentic flavor
- Large 32 oz. jars suitable for regular use
Cons:- May be too zesty for some tastes
- Limited flavor variety, focusing only on zesty style
Best for: Fans of authentic Amish recipes seeking a flavorful, zesty pickle for everyday meals or gatherings.
Not ideal for: Those who prefer milder, less spicy pickles or need detailed nutritional info for dietary reasons.
- Quantity:2 jars
- Size:32 oz. each
- Flavor:Zesty Amish-style
Our verdict“Ideal for enthusiasts of traditional Amish flavors who want a bold, zesty pickle in bulk.”
Amish Valley Products Bread and Butter Pickles – 32 oz Glass Jar
This pick offers a crisp, slightly sweet flavor that complements a variety of dishes, making it a reliable choice for traditional bread and butter lovers. Compared with the Zesty Amish pickles, this one is milder and more suited to those who prefer a straightforward, sweet-tangy profile. Its all-natural ingredients and absence of preservatives or artificial coloring appeal to health-conscious buyers seeking simplicity and authenticity. The crisp texture and traditional recipe make it a versatile condiment for burgers, BBQ, or snacking, though its flavor options are limited, and the sugar content could be a concern for some diets. This pick makes the most sense for those who want classic, non-spicy bread and butter pickles made from scratch.
Pros:- Made from a traditional Amish recipe
- No preservatives or artificial coloring
- Crisp and slightly sweet flavor
Cons:- Limited flavor variation
- Contains sugar, which may not suit low-sugar diets
Best for: Home cooks seeking a reliable, all-natural sweet and tangy pickle for everyday meals.
Not ideal for: Buyers wanting spicy or zesty flavor profiles or those monitoring sugar intake closely.
- Weight:32 oz
- Container:Glass jar
- Flavor:Sweet and tangy
Our verdict“This is a solid choice for those wanting a straightforward, all-natural classic bread and butter pickle.”
Amish Wedding Foods Bread & Butter Pickles, 2 x 32 oz. Quart Jars
This product emphasizes traditional Amish craftsmanship, with small-batch production ensuring quality and care. Compared to the other Amish Wedding options, these jars provide a consistent, classic bread and butter flavor that appeals to purists. The focus on no preservatives or artificial coloring aligns with health-conscious preferences, making them suitable for those who prioritize authenticity. However, the flavor profile is limited to the classic sweet and tangy style, which might not satisfy those looking for zesty or spicy variations. The lack of detailed shelf life info could concern buyers needing long-term storage guidance. This pick is best for traditionalists who value small-batch Amish quality in a familiar flavor.
Pros:- Made with traditional Amish recipes
- High-quality small batch production
- Great for adding authentic flavor to meals
Cons:- Limited flavor options
- No specific shelf life or expiration info provided
Best for: Purists and traditional Amish recipe fans wanting small-batch, authentic flavor in bulk.
Not ideal for: Those seeking innovative or zesty flavors, or specific shelf life details.
- Size:2 x 32 oz. jars
- Made in:Holmes County, Ohio
- Flavor:Classic bread and butter
Our verdict“Ideal for those who value traditional Amish craftsmanship and classic flavor in a bulk package.”
Bubbies Pickles Variety Pack – 32 oz Bread & Butter, 32 oz Dill, 25 oz Sauerkraut
This variety pack from Bubbies shines for those seeking probiotic-rich, naturally fermented pickles, especially if gut health is a priority. Compared with the Mrs. Wages Mix, which simplifies pickling but offers less variety, this pack provides a spectrum of flavors that can elevate many dishes. The fermentation process preserves beneficial probiotics, making it a smart choice for health-conscious buyers. However, the pronounced fermented taste might not appeal to everyone, and some could find the texture too crunchy or the flavor too tangy. This pick makes sense for those who want authentic, probiotic-rich options for snacks or meals, but less so for those preferring milder, less fermented flavors.
Pros:- Naturally fermented and probiotic-rich for improved gut health
- No preservatives, gluten-free, and free of added sugars for clean eating
- Includes three classic flavors—bread & butter, dill, and sauerkraut—adding variety
Cons:- Strong fermented taste may not suit all palates
- Limited flavor options within the pack can feel restrictive
- Some may find the texture too crunchy for their preference
Best for: Health-conscious consumers who want probiotic benefits and versatility in their pickles and fermented foods
Not ideal for: Casual pickle lovers or those who dislike strong fermented flavors or crunchy textures
- Product Type:Variety Pack
- Contents:Bread & Butter, Dill, Sauerkraut
- Fermentation:Naturally fermented
- Size:33 oz (Bread & Butter), 32 oz (Dill), 25 oz (Sauerkraut)
- Dietary:Gluten-Free, Preservative-Free
Our verdict“This pick is ideal for those seeking probiotic-rich, naturally fermented options with a variety of flavors, but not for those preferring milder or less fermented tastes.”
Mrs. Wages Bread and Butter Pickle Mix 5.3 oz
Mrs. Wages offers a straightforward solution for those who want to produce classic bread and butter pickles at home quickly and easily. Compared with the Bubbies Pack, which provides ready-to-eat fermented products, this mix requires some effort but ensures fresh, customized results. It’s perfect for beginners or those with limited space, since it produces a modest batch and involves straightforward preparation. The main tradeoff is that it needs additional fresh ingredients, like cucumbers, and it’s limited to small quantities per batch. If you enjoy hands-on pickling and control over ingredients, this product makes a lot of sense; for larger batches or more convenience, the other options are better suited.
Pros:- Simple, quick preparation for homemade pickles
- Includes all necessary dry ingredients in one package
- Trusted brand with consistent reviews for flavor and reliability
Cons:- Limited to small batches (5.3 oz), requiring multiple batches for large needs
- Requires additional fresh cucumbers and ingredients
- Some users may prefer more complex or unique flavor profiles
Best for: Home cooks who want to make small batches of fresh bread and butter pickles with minimal effort
Not ideal for: Large families or those seeking a quick, no-fuss solution with ready-to-eat results
- Package Size:5.3 oz
- Yield:Small batch
- Includes:Dry pickle mix
- Brand:Mrs. Wages
- Dietary:Preservative-Free
Our verdict“This mix is perfect for beginners or those making small batches, but not ideal for large-scale or convenience-focused pickling projects.”
Mrs. Wages Bread and Butter Pickles Quick Process Mix, 6 Pack (5.3 oz each)
The Mrs. Wages Quick Process Mix stands out for its ability to produce large quantities—up to 7 quarts per pouch—making it ideal for families or gatherings. Compared with the smaller single-pack, this 6-pack offers great value and convenience for frequent picklers or those wanting plenty of homemade bread and butter pickles without fuss. It’s also quick to prepare, with ready-to-eat pickles in about 24 hours. The main limitation is that it requires chopping fresh cucumbers, onions, and peppers, which adds prep time and mess. Additionally, the flavor is strictly traditional, so those seeking more flavor variation might find it limiting. Overall, this pack makes a lot of sense for regular use but isn’t ideal for those who prefer pre-cut, ready-to-eat options or smaller batches.
Pros:- Yields up to 7 quarts per pouch, great for large needs
- Quick to prepare—ready in about 24 hours
- Kosher certified, free of artificial colors and flavors
Cons:- Requires chopping and prep work of fresh vegetables
- Limited to bread and butter flavor only
- Bulk packaging might be cumbersome for small households
Best for: Families or hosts who want to make large quantities of bread and butter pickles easily and quickly
Not ideal for: Individuals with limited kitchen space or those preferring pre-made or less labor-intensive options
- Quantity:6 pouches
- Weight per pouch:5.3 oz
- Yield:7 quarts per pouch
- Certification:Kosher
- Includes:Dry pickle mix
Our verdict“This large-pack pickling mix is ideal for frequent, large-scale bread and butter pickle making, but less suited for small or casual projects due to prep requirements.”
How We Picked
I evaluated each product based on flavor quality, ingredient transparency, ease of preparation, value for the price, and versatility. Recipes that deliver consistent, flavorful results while accommodating different skill levels ranked higher. I also considered packaging options, shelf life, and whether the product was designed for immediate use or longer-term storage. This approach ensures that the selected products cater to a range of needs—from beginners seeking simple mixes to experienced cooks wanting authentic homemade results. The ranking reflects a balance between convenience, flavor, and overall value, helping buyers find the best fit for their preferences and experience level.Factors to Consider When Choosing Bread And Butter Pickle Recipe
Choosing the right bread and butter pickle recipe depends on several practical factors. Beyond flavor, consider how much time you want to invest, your skill level, and whether you prefer a homemade approach or a quick mix. Storage and packaging are also important, especially if you plan to make large batches or gift jars. Understanding these considerations can help prevent common mistakes like overcomplicating a simple recipe or choosing options that don’t match your taste preferences. The following sections highlight key aspects to keep in mind when selecting a bread and butter pickle recipe.Ease of Preparation
If you’re new to pickling, opting for a mix or quick process recipe can save time and reduce stress. However, these options often sacrifice some flavor complexity that comes with homemade recipes. More experienced cooks might prefer from-scratch recipes that allow customization and control over ingredients. Keep in mind that some mixes require additional ingredients, which can add to the overall effort. Balancing convenience with your skill level is key to enjoying the process and results.
Flavor Profile
Flavor preferences vary from sweet and mild to zesty and tangy. Some recipes emphasize natural, fresh ingredients, while others incorporate spices or vinegar blends for a punchier taste. Reading reviews or ingredient lists can help determine if a recipe aligns with your flavor expectations. Remember, the quality of ingredients used can make a significant difference in final taste, especially for homemade options. Choose a recipe that matches your preferred level of sweetness and acidity.
Ingredient Quality and Preservatives
High-quality ingredients lead to better flavor and texture, especially in homemade recipes. For mixes, check for natural preservatives and minimal artificial additives if you prioritize health. Budget options might include preservatives or fillers that impact flavor and shelf life. If you’re making a large batch for gifting or long-term storage, ingredient quality becomes even more critical. Prioritize products that clearly list ingredients and avoid unnecessary preservatives for a more authentic taste.
Jar Size and Packaging
The size of the jars affects both cost and convenience. Larger jars often offer better value but can be cumbersome to store or use quickly. Smaller jars are more manageable, especially for tasting or limited household needs. Packaging also influences freshness—vacuum-sealed jars tend to last longer, while resealable options add convenience. Consider your storage space and how quickly you plan to use the pickles when choosing between different jar sizes.
Price and Value
While premium recipes and mixes tend to cost more upfront, they often deliver superior flavor and ease of use. Conversely, store-brand or budget options may be cheaper but could compromise on ingredient quality or flavor complexity. Evaluate whether the extra cost aligns with your expectations for taste and effort. Sometimes, investing in a high-quality mix or fresh ingredients can save money in the long run by reducing the need for additional seasoning or adjustments.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I customize bread and butter pickle recipes to suit my taste?
Absolutely. Many recipes, especially homemade ones, allow for adjustments in sweetness, acidity, and spice levels. You can experiment with different types of sugar, vinegars, or spices like mustard seeds, turmeric, or cinnamon to tailor the flavor. Keep in mind that altering ingredients might change the preservation qualities, so follow tested guidelines if you plan to store jars long-term. Customization can help you create a signature bread and butter pickle that matches your personal preferences perfectly.
How long do homemade bread and butter pickles last?
Homemade pickles stored properly in sterilized jars can last up to a year or more, thanks to vinegar and sugar acting as preservatives. It’s essential to follow proper canning procedures to ensure safety and longevity. Once opened, the shelf life shortens to about 1-2 months in the refrigerator. Always check for signs of spoilage like mold, off-smell, or discoloration before consuming stored pickles. Proper sealing and storage are key to maximizing shelf life.
Are pre-made mixes safe for long-term storage?
Yes, if they are commercially produced and properly stored, mixes designed for pickling are safe for long-term use. These mixes often include preservatives that extend shelf life. However, it’s best to use them by the date printed on the package and store them in a cool, dry place. When preparing pickles with these mixes, follow the instructions closely to ensure safety and optimal flavor. They provide a convenient way to enjoy homemade-style pickles without extensive effort.
What equipment do I need for making bread and butter pickles from scratch?
Basic equipment includes sterilized glass jars with lids, a large pot for boiling, a knife for slicing, and a saucepan for preparing the brine. A canning rack and jar lifter are helpful for safe handling during processing. Some cooks prefer a mandoline for even slicing, and a thermometer can help monitor vinegar acidity if you’re adjusting recipes. Investing in quality jars and proper sterilization tools ensures safety and preserves flavor for longer storage periods.
Is it worth buying a bread and butter pickle mix or should I make it from scratch?
This depends on your priorities. Mixes offer a quick, consistent, and less messy way to make pickles, ideal for busy schedules or beginners. From-scratch recipes, on the other hand, give you complete control over ingredients and flavor complexity, which many seasoned cooks prefer. If you value authenticity and customization, making your own might be worth the extra effort. However, for reliable, fast results, a quality mix provides a great balance of convenience and taste.
Conclusion
For casual cooks or those new to pickling, the Mrs. Wages Bread and Butter Pickle Mix offers a straightforward, reliable starting point. If you prioritize flavor authenticity and have some experience, the Amish Wedding Foods All Natural Bread N Butter Pickles deliver a fresh, natural taste that stands out. For large batch enthusiasts and gifting, the Amish Valley Products Bread and Butter Pickles in glass jars provide both quality and quantity. Those seeking variety will appreciate the Bubbies Pickles Variety Pack, while experienced home cooks aiming for a signature flavor should consider customizing recipes or making from scratch. Your ideal choice hinges on your skill level, time, and flavor preferences.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Fall Picks
fall essentials
