15 Best Butter Popcorn Brands You Need to Try Right Now

As popcorn enthusiasts, we all know that feeling of getting comfy on the couch, the soft light of the TV glowing, and the tempting aroma of buttery popcorn filling the room.

But with so many options out there, it can be daunting to find the perfect buttery snack to elevate your movie night or satisfy your craving. That's why we've curated a list of the 15 best butter popcorn brands that you need to experience right now.

Each brand brings its own unique twist to the classic buttery flavor, and we're here to guide you through the buttery goodness.

So, whether you're a die-hard fan of buttery classics or looking to explore new flavors, we've got you covered.

Key Takeaways

• Orville Redenbachers Ultimate Butter Popcorn, Popcorn, Indiana Original Movie Theater Popcorn, and ACT II Xtreme Butter Popcorn are popular brands to consider.
• The Buttery Flavor Popcorn Topping (Gallon Only) offers a gourmet flavor and is ideal for popcorn bars, but there may be issues with delivery and product quantity.
• Brims Movie Theater Butter Flavored Premium Popcorn comes in a substantial size and delivers an authentic taste, but there are reports of inconsistent quality.
• Stonehedge Farms Butter Toffee Flavored Popcorn offers an irresistible butter toffee flavor in a resealable tub, but there are mixed reviews on taste and quality.

Orville Redenbachers Ultimate Butter Popcorn, Classic Bag, 12-Count

For those seeking a tasty and convenient snack option, Orville Redenbachers Ultimate Butter Popcorn, Classic Bag, 12-Count, offers a satisfying blend of whole grains, fiber, and a delicious buttery flavor. Made from 100% whole grains, this popcorn is a good source of fiber and a gluten-free snack. With 0g trans fat per serving, it's a healthier alternative to other name brands.

Despite being slightly too salty for my liking, the popcorn was light and fluffy when popped in my older microwave oven. The affordable price and lower calorie and fat content make it a worthwhile choice. The packaging is great, and the quick delivery adds to the overall satisfaction. The slight saltiness and wonderful taste make it an enjoyable snack, perfect for sharing with friends.

Best For: Those looking for a lower calorie and fat content popcorn with a satisfying blend of whole grains and fiber.

Pros:

• Light and fluffy popcorn with a wonderful taste
• Affordable price and quick delivery
• Good source of fiber and gluten-free

Cons:

• Slightly too salty for some

Popcorn, Indiana Original Movie Theater Popcorn (Pack of 6, 5.5 Ounce)

Indulge in the classic flavor and exceptional quality of Popcorn, Indiana Original Movie Theater Popcorn. This popcorn is perfect for those seeking an authentic movie theater experience at home. It comes in a 5.5-ounce pack of 6 bags and offers a kosher and gluten-free snack without any artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives.

Made with the finest popcorn, real butter, and salt, this popcorn delivers a fresh, buttery flavor that transports you to the magic of the movies. While some customers mention that it can be a bit salty, overall, positive reviews highlight the delicious taste and quality.

Conveniently available on Amazon, this popcorn can be subscribed and saved for added convenience. With its classic movie theater taste and positive customer satisfaction, Popcorn, Indiana Original Movie Theater Popcorn is a great choice for events, concession stands, or simply enjoying with the whole family.

Best For: Movie enthusiasts and families seeking an authentic movie theater popcorn experience at home.

Pros:

• Fresh, buttery flavor that transports you to the magic of the movies
• Kosher and gluten-free certification
• Good value for the price with six large bags in each carton

Cons:

• Some customers mention the popcorn being too salty

ACT II Xtreme Butter Popcorn, 2.75 Oz, 12 Ct

With its intense buttery taste and high-impact flavor, ACT II Xtreme Butter Popcorn is the perfect choice for popcorn enthusiasts seeking a delicious and convenient snacking option. This microwave popcorn delivers a warm and buttery taste that pleases every palate, making it a preferred option over popcorn from local grocery stores.

The 2.75 oz size is ideal for individual servings, and the 12 bags in a box offer great value for money. Customers love the fact that the popcorn is full to the very top of the bag with all kernels popping, and the microwave preparation is quick and hassle-free.

While some customers feel that the popcorn has less butter than movie theater popcorn, many enjoy the perfectly balanced flavor without the need for extra butter or salt.

Overall, ACT II Xtreme Butter Popcorn provides a convenient and satisfying snacking experience.

Best For: Popcorn enthusiasts looking for a convenient and delicious snacking option with an intense buttery flavor.

Pros:

• High-impact buttery flavor
• Quick and hassle-free microwave preparation
• Individual servings in 2.75 oz size, offering great value for money

Cons:

• Some customers feel it has less butter than movie theater popcorn

Buttery Flavor Popcorn Topping (1 Liter)

If you want to elevate your at-home popcorn experience with a rich and authentic movie theater buttery flavor, the Buttery Flavor Popcorn Topping (1 Liter) is an excellent choice. This topping offers easy pouring at room temperature, with no need for refrigeration, even after opening. It can be added during or after the popcorn cycle and doesn't require melting. Customers rave about its taste, noting that it surpasses movie theater popcorn and provides a huge butter boost. It's also seen as a better alternative to using melted butter and is more economical than other butter flavor toppings.

With a large wide opening for easy pouring and the ability to be used with a spray bottle, this topping is a must-try for those seeking a genuine movie theater popcorn taste at home.

Best For: Home theater enthusiasts and popcorn lovers who want to replicate the authentic buttery taste of movie theater popcorn at home.

Pros:

• Easy pouring at room temperature
• No refrigeration required, even after opening
• Provides a rich and authentic movie theater buttery flavor

Cons:

• May not be suitable for those who don't prefer a buttery flavor on their popcorn

Orville Redenbachers Movie Theater Butter Popcorn Tub, 3.9 Ounce

For those seeking a delicious popcorn experience with real butter and no artificial preservatives, Orville Redenbachers Movie Theater Butter Popcorn Tub, 3.9 Ounce, is the ideal choice. This 3.9 oz. tub of Orville Redenbachers Movie Theater Butter Popcorn is perfect for creating that authentic movie theater popcorn experience at home.

It stands out as the only leading popcorn brand that uses real butter, and it contains no artificial preservatives, flavors, or dyes. Made with high-quality, non-GMO popcorn kernels, every handful from this tub of delicious Movie Theater Butter Popcorn transports you from your couch to the theater. Not only does it pop great and leave very few unpopped seeds, but it's also easy to make, providing fresh movie theater popcorn without the hefty bill.

Plus, it can be paired with sweet snacks and comes in a tub for a nostalgic 'bucket of popcorn' experience.

Best For: Movie enthusiasts looking for an authentic movie theater popcorn experience at home.

Pros:

• Uses real butter for a rich flavor
• Made with high-quality, non-GMO popcorn kernels
• Easy to make and leaves very few unpopped seeds

Cons:

• May not be suitable for individuals with dairy allergies

Buttery Flavor Popcorn Topping (Gallon w/Pump)

The Buttery Flavor Popcorn Topping (Gallon w/Pump) offers a convenient and flavorful option for enhancing your popcorn experience, making it a great choice for popcorn enthusiasts who crave that authentic buttery taste. The easy pouring at room temperature and the fact that no refrigeration is required, even after opening, make it a hassle-free addition to your popcorn.

However, some customers have experienced issues with the pump, which shoots out butter forcefully and leaks for a few hours after use, causing a mess and waste. To address this, it's suggested to protect yourself from the forceful butter spray by pumping slowly and tipping the bottle at an angle after use to prevent dripping. Alternatively, considering replacing the pump or finding alternative methods for dispensing the butter.

Despite the pump issues, users have praised the product for its authentic and delicious butter flavor, making it a popular choice for at-home movie nights.

Best For: Movie enthusiasts and popcorn lovers who want an authentic buttery flavor for their home movie nights.

Pros:

• Authentic and delicious butter flavor
• Easy pouring at room temperature
• No refrigeration required, even after opening

Cons:

• Forceful butter spray from the pump

Winona Pure Popcorn Butter Spray Oil (Butter Flavor, 5 oz, 3 Pack)

Winona Pure Popcorn Butter Spray Oil offers a rich and buttery flavor that's perfect for those seeking a low-calorie alternative to real butter on their popcorn. This 5-ounce aerosol canola oil spray delivers intense buttery taste without the mess or added saturated fat. With zero calories per serving, it's keto-friendly and can aid in weight management.

Customers have praised its delicious flavor, with some preferring it over real butter for its convenience and taste. However, there have been complaints about the spray nozzle's wide dispersion and concerns about the amount of product in each can.

Compared to real butter, this spray oil helps reduce calorie intake, with one spray equating to only 2 calories, making it a healthier alternative. Whether it's for movie night or a guilt-free snack, Winona Pure Popcorn Butter Spray Oil is a satisfying choice.

Best For: Those looking for a low-calorie, buttery popcorn flavor without the mess or added saturated fat.

Pros:

• Intense buttery taste without the greasy mess of real butter
• Zero calories per serving, making it keto-friendly and suitable for weight management
• Versatile, can be used on various foods like pasta, rice, and veggies

Cons:

• Some customers have experienced wide dispersion from the spray nozzle

Amish Country Popcorn Buttery Popcorn Topping (16 oz Jar)

With its rich buttery flavor and non-GMO, gluten-free ingredients, Amish Country Popcorn Buttery Popcorn Topping is an excellent choice for those seeking a healthier yet indulgent popcorn experience. The 16 oz jar offers a low-calorie option that's also free from tree nuts and peanuts, catering to a wide range of dietary preferences. Customer reviews highlight its authentic movie theater butter taste, making it a popular choice for enhancing the flavor of air-popped popcorn.

However, some users found the consistency to be thick and challenging to coat the popcorn evenly. While the product delivers on taste, there are concerns about the use of dimethyl polysiloxane, which may impact individual preferences.

Overall, the Amish Country Popcorn Buttery Popcorn Topping provides an enjoyable buttery flavor, offering value for money and a healthier alternative to traditional butter toppings.

Best For: Movie enthusiasts and health-conscious individuals looking for an authentic buttery popcorn experience.

Pros:

• Authentic movie theater butter taste
• Non-GMO and gluten-free
• Low calorie option

Cons:

• Thick consistency may make it challenging to coat popcorn evenly

Pop Secret Popcorn, Movie Theater Butter, 3 Ounce Microwave Bags, 30 Count

For those who love the indulgent taste of movie theater butter popcorn, Pop Secret Popcorn, Movie Theater Butter, 3 Ounce Microwave Bags, 30 Count, offers a convenient and satisfying snack option. The 30-count box of 3oz bags provides a premium, all-natural jumbo size popcorn, delivering a slightly sweeter butter flavor and classic crunch. Customers rave about the convenience and delicious taste, making it their favorite snack at any time. The product has received glowing reviews, with many highlighting the ease of use and the perfect balance of butter and sea salt. With simple microwave directions and no need to add anything, this popcorn makes for a hassle-free and tasty treat.

Pop Secret Popcorn is a highly recommended choice for those seeking the authentic movie theater butter popcorn experience in the comfort of their own home.

Best For: Movie enthusiasts and popcorn lovers seeking an authentic movie theater butter popcorn experience at home.

Pros:

• Convenient and satisfying snack option
• Premium all-natural jumbo size with slightly sweeter butter flavor
• No need to add anything, hassle-free preparation

Cons:

• May not be suitable for those with dietary restrictions

AMC Theatres Extra Butter Movie Theatre Popcorn Bundle – 6 Total Bags of Microwave Popcorn

The AMC Theatres Extra Butter Movie Theatre Popcorn Bundle is an ideal choice for anyone seeking an authentic movie theater popcorn experience at home or on the go. With 6 total bags of microwave popcorn, each 2.7oz bag is crafted from wholesome, natural ingredients and completely devoid of trans fats. The popcorn is composed entirely of whole grains and is free from gluten, making it a healthier option.

The robust movie theater butter flavor and the pourable, buttery-flavored topping included in the bundle pay homage to the luxurious, buttery essence and alluring aroma of AMC Theatres' renowned movie theater recipe. Customers have praised the finest kernels for larger, more tender popcorn and fewer unpopped kernels, truly delivering an authentic taste of movie popcorn. Additionally, the bundled Bear Magnet adds a fun, collectible element to the experience.

Our reviews and positive attributes make it clear that AMC Theatres Extra Butter Movie Theatre Popcorn Bundle is a top choice for an indulgent and flavorful popcorn experience.

Best For: Movie enthusiasts and families seeking an authentic and indulgent movie theater popcorn experience at home.

Pros:

• Robust movie theater butter flavor
• Finest kernels for tender popcorn
• Loved by kids

Cons:

• Choking hazard for children under 3 years old

ACT II Xtreme Butter Microwave Popcorn Bags, 3-Count (Pack of 12)

If you crave a quick and delicious snack, the ACT II Xtreme Butter Microwave Popcorn Bags are a perfect choice for satisfying your popcorn cravings in just 2 minutes. Packed with extra butter flavor, these fluffy microwave popcorn bags contain 100% whole grain popcorn and 0 grams of trans fat, making them a tasty and relatively healthy snack option.

Reviews mention the convenience of the microwave preparation and the enjoyable buttery taste without the need to add extra butter. While some users note a mild butter taste and a sweetish flavor, overall satisfaction seems high, with comments highlighting the deliciousness and consistency of the popcorn.

Availability in stores might be limited, and purchasing from online retailers like Amazon could offer better pricing and convenience. Personal experiences rave about the quick preparation, light and fluffy texture, and overall satisfaction with the product.

Best For: Popcorn enthusiasts who crave a quick and buttery snack without the hassle of melting and adding extra butter.

Pros:

• Quick and easy microwave preparation
• Enjoyable buttery flavor without the need for additional butter
• Light and fluffy texture

Cons:

• Limited availability in stores

Farmer Jons Popcorn Butter Bash Bag, 144oz of Bulk Butter Popped Popcorn

Handmade in small batches with farm fresh popcorn from Iowa fields, Farmer Jon's Popcorn Butter Bash Bag offers a satisfying crunch and robust buttery flavor, making it an ideal choice for popcorn bars and mixing with other flavors and treats. This 144oz bulk bag is non-GMO, whole grain, gluten-free, and free from trans fat, MSG, preservatives, and artificial colors.

Farmer Jon's Popcorn, a third-generation company, has been growing and selling Iowa popcorn since 1940, ensuring meticulous craftsmanship and a fresh flavor guarantee. Customer reviews highlight positive experiences with taste, freshness, and customer service, although there have been some issues with delivery and product quantity. Despite a previous order being discontinued, the overall feedback praises the great flavor, freshness, and value for money.

Best For: Popcorn enthusiasts seeking a high-quality, buttery, and satisfyingly crunchy popcorn experience.

Pros:

• Gourmet flavor with a robust buttery taste
• Non-GMO, whole grain, and gluten-free
• Ideal for popcorn bars and mixing with other flavors and treats

Cons:

• Issues with delivery and product quantity

Buttery Flavor Popcorn Topping (Gallon Only)

For popcorn enthusiasts seeking an authentic movie theater butter taste, the Buttery Flavor Popcorn Topping (Gallon Only) provides a convenient and delicious option to enhance our popcorn experience.

This topping is easy to pour at room temperature and requires no refrigeration, even after opening. It can be added during or after the popcorn cycle, without any melting required.

Customer reviews rave about its movie theater butter taste, noting that it's not overly greasy or oily. Users describe it as addictive and highly recommended for fans of movie theater popcorn. It offers a stronger butter taste and is less oily compared to other soy-based oils. According to positive customer experiences, it provides a great taste with less oily flavor.

Overall, the product garners high satisfaction, making it a must-have for popcorn lovers.

Best For: Popcorn lovers and enthusiasts seeking an authentic movie theater butter taste for their popcorn.

Pros:

• Authentic movie theater butter taste
• Easy pouring at room temperature
• No refrigeration required

Cons:

• Only available in gallon size

Brims Movie Theater Butter Flavored Premium Popcorn (large 8 oz Bag)

Brims Movie Theater Butter Flavored Premium Popcorn, despite mixed reviews, offers a gluten-free option for those seeking a rich, buttery popcorn experience. Some customers have expressed disappointment, citing chewy and stale popcorn, while others have praised its delicious, movie theater-like taste.

The product comes in a large 8 oz bag, providing a substantial quantity for indulging in a movie night at home. However, some buyers have found the price not commensurate with the quality received, prompting them to seek alternative, more cost-effective options. Additionally, there have been challenges with the return and purchase experience, with some customers unable to return the product and finding the shipping costs prohibitive.

While the product has its drawbacks, those who've received a fresh bag have enjoyed the delightful buttery flavor reminiscent of the movie theater experience.

Best For: Movie enthusiasts who enjoy a rich, buttery popcorn experience but are willing to take a chance on varying quality.

Pros:

• Offers a gluten-free option for a buttery popcorn experience.
• Provides a substantial 8 oz bag for a movie night at home.
• Delivers a delightful buttery flavor reminiscent of the movie theater experience for those who receive a fresh bag.

Cons:

• Inconsistent quality with reports of chewy and stale popcorn.

Stonehedge Farms Butter Toffee Flavored Popcorn – 32oz Reclosable Tub

The Stonehedge Farms Butter Toffee Flavored Popcorn is a gourmet treat for popcorn enthusiasts seeking a delightful and authentic snacking experience. It offers an irresistible butter toffee flavor and superior snacking delight. This 32-ounce reclosable tub is made in the USA and is gluten-free, ensuring a quality snacking option for various dietary needs.

The harmonious blend of buttery richness and smooth toffee offers a gourmet excellence in every bite. The specially designed tub with a resealable lid preserves the freshness and delightful crunch, ensuring a guaranteed minimum 6-month shelf life when sold by Mighty Merchandise.

However, it's important to note that the product has received mixed reviews on taste and quality. Some customers enjoy the flavor and freshness, while others have experienced hard kernels and unsatisfactory taste. While there is positive feedback from customers who enjoyed the product, there are mixed recommendations to buy the product due to varying experiences with freshness and taste.

Best For: Popcorn enthusiasts who enjoy the irresistible allure of butter toffee flavor and seek a gourmet snacking experience.

Pros:

• Irresistible butter toffee flavor
• Specially designed tub with a resealable lid for preserving freshness
• Made in the USA and gluten-free, catering to various dietary needs

Cons:

• Mixed reviews on taste and quality, with some customers experiencing hard kernels and unsatisfactory taste

Factors to Consider When Choosing Butter Popcorn

When choosing butter popcorn, we need to consider various factors that can greatly influence our snacking experience. From different flavor profiles to the nutritional information, there are several aspects to weigh when making a selection.

Additionally, packaging options, customer preferences, and popcorn preparation methods play a significant role in our decision-making process.

Flavor Profiles

When selecting butter popcorn, it's important to consider the diverse flavor profiles available, ranging from traditional to gourmet options. Some brands offer a slightly sweeter butter flavor, while others boast an intense, robust buttery taste. It's crucial to consider the balance of salt and butter in the flavor profile, as well as the level of sweetness, to find the best fit for your preferences.

Additionally, look for popcorn that offers an authentic and top-quality snacking experience, with a focus on flavor intensity and freshness. Checking for product features such as gluten-free and non-GMO options is also important, along with considering the convenience of packaging and shelf life.

Nutritional Information

Considering the nutritional information is essential when selecting butter popcorn, as it can vary significantly between brands and impact dietary choices.

When comparing options, check the label for details on calories, fat, fiber, and other nutrients per serving. Opt for brands with lower trans fat content and higher whole grain and fiber content for a healthier choice.

Additionally, be mindful of the nutritional content of any toppings or flavorings, as they may contain additional calories and fats.

Portion sizes are also important to consider, as overconsumption can lead to higher intake of calories and fats.

It's crucial to keep in mind that individual dietary needs and preferences may influence the choice of butter popcorn based on its nutritional information.

Always make informed decisions based on your specific dietary requirements.

Packaging Options

Exploring various packaging options for butter popcorn is essential for ensuring freshness and convenience in snacking.

When choosing packaging, consider the convenience of resealable tubs or bags for easy storage.

Evaluate the size to ensure it meets your snacking needs, whether for individual enjoyment, sharing, or events like movie nights.

Look for clear usage instructions, such as easy pouring and compatibility with popcorn cycles, to simplify the snacking experience.

Assess the value and cost-effectiveness, considering the quantity provided and any additional features like buttery flavor packets.

Check for versatility, such as suitability for gifting, mixing with other flavors, or using with specific popcorn brands or equipment.

Customer Preferences

We find that customer preferences for butter popcorn often revolve around a balance of saltiness and butteriness, as well as considerations for calorie and fat content. Some customers may lean towards lower calorie and fat options, seeking healthier choices.

Additionally, convenient and easy-to-use packaging is highly preferred, as it enhances the overall snacking experience. Many customers also express a desire for popcorn that closely resembles the taste of movie theater popcorn, as it evokes a sense of nostalgia and authenticity.

Furthermore, a common preference among customers is for a buttery flavor that isn't overly oily or greasy, ensuring a satisfying and enjoyable consumption experience. Understanding and catering to these customer preferences is essential for butter popcorn brands to meet the diverse needs and desires of their consumers.

Popcorn Preparation

When choosing butter popcorn, it's essential to consider the type of popcorn and the specific butter flavors available. We should take into account whether it's microwave, air-popped, or pre-popped, as each type can affect the taste and texture of the popcorn.

Additionally, reviewing the flavor options is crucial. Look for specific butter flavors such as movie theater butter, extra butter, or butter toffee to find the one that best suits your preferences. It's also important to check for additional ingredients like non-GMO corn, gluten-free options, or added fiber, depending on your dietary requirements.

Consider the packaging and portion size as well, evaluating the quantity of popcorn in each package and the type of packaging offered.

Lastly, reading customer reviews can provide valuable insights into overall satisfaction, taste, quality, and any common issues mentioned.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Are the Nutritional Values and Ingredients for Each of the Listed Butter Popcorn Products?

We can provide the nutritional values and ingredients for each of the listed butter popcorn products.

We'll ensure that you have all the information you need to make informed choices about these products.

Let's dive into the details of the nutritional content and ingredients of the butter popcorn brands so you can enjoy them with confidence.

Are Any of the Listed Butter Popcorn Products Suitable for Individuals With Dietary Restrictions, Such as Gluten-Free or Dairy-Free Diets?

Yes, some of the listed butter popcorn products are suitable for individuals with dietary restrictions, such as gluten-free or dairy-free diets.

These products have been carefully selected to cater to a wide range of dietary needs, ensuring that everyone can enjoy delicious butter popcorn without worrying about their restrictions.

We understand the importance of providing options for those with dietary limitations and have taken that into consideration when selecting the featured brands.

Do Any of the Listed Products Offer Options for Reduced-Fat or Lower-Calorie Butter Popcorn?

Yes, some of the listed products offer reduced-fat or lower-calorie butter popcorn options. They're suited for individuals looking for a healthier snack choice without compromising on flavor.

These options provide a satisfying popcorn experience while being mindful of calorie and fat intake. It's great to have these alternatives available for those who are conscious of their dietary choices but still want to enjoy buttery popcorn.

Are There Any Special Storage Instructions for the Listed Butter Popcorn Products to Maintain Freshness and Flavor?

We always store our butter popcorn in a cool, dry place to maintain its freshness and flavor.

It's important to seal the bag tightly after opening to prevent air exposure.

Some brands recommend refrigeration to extend shelf life, so we follow those instructions as well.

Keeping the popcorn away from heat and sunlight also helps preserve its delicious taste.

These simple storage practices ensure our butter popcorn stays tasty for longer.

Can Any of the Listed Butter Popcorn Products Be Purchased in Bulk or in Larger Quantities for Events or Gatherings?

Yes, some of the listed butter popcorn products can be purchased in bulk or larger quantities for events or gatherings.

It's convenient for larger gatherings and can save money in the long run.

Check the product details for bulk purchase options, and consider factors like shelf life and storage requirements when buying in larger quantities.

It's a great way to ensure everyone gets to enjoy their favorite butter popcorn at your next event.

Conclusion

So, grab a bag of buttery popcorn and let your taste buds take a trip to the movies.

With so many delicious options to choose from, you're sure to find the perfect buttery snack for your next movie night.

Let the rich, creamy flavor of the popcorn melt in your mouth like warm, comforting butter on a cold day.

It's a taste sensation that will transport you to a world of pure, buttery bliss.