Have you ever thought about incorporating apple butter into your breakfast spread, alongside classic options like jam and honey?

The rich, velvety texture and deep, caramelized flavor of apple butter can take your morning toast or muffin to a whole new level.

But with so many brands out there, how do you know which one to choose?

Let's explore the top 14 apple butter brands that are sure to elevate your breakfast game and add a delicious twist to your morning routine.

Key Takeaways

Advertisement

• Popular brands of apple butter include Braswells, Musselmans, Amish Valley, McCutcheons, and Tennessee's Best.
• Customers value apple butter that is made with natural ingredients and hand-stirred in small batches for a homemade taste.
• Apple butter is praised for its delicious flavor, versatility as a breakfast spread, and ability to evoke nostalgic memories.
• Considerations when choosing apple butter include taste and consistency, ingredients and quality, pricing and affordability, packaging and shipping, and customer satisfaction.

BRASWELLS Apple Butter, 12.5 OZ

Braswells Apple Butter, 12.5 oz, is an ideal choice for those seeking a high-quality, flavorful breakfast spread made with fresh, ripe apples and natural ingredients. Hand-stirred in small batches for a homemade taste, this apple butter boasts a richly spiced, thick jam-like consistency that's perfect for spreading on toast, breakfast breads, muffins, and scones. Customers have shared positive feedback about its delicious taste and quality, with some noting the delightful combination of pumpkin and apple flavors. Its versatility extends beyond just a spread, as it pairs seamlessly with English muffins, croissants, cornbread, biscuits, and even as an addition to oatmeal and desserts. While available for purchase on Amazon, it's worth noting that some customers found a lower price for the product locally after initially ordering online.

Best For: Breakfast enthusiasts looking for a high-quality and versatile apple butter spread with a rich, homemade taste.

Pros:

• Made with fresh, ripe apples and natural ingredients
• Versatile, pairing well with a variety of breakfast foods and desserts
• Hand-stirred in small batches for a homemade taste

Cons:

• Some customers reported issues with broken and expired products

Musselmans Apple Butter (2 Pack, Total of 34oz)

For breakfast enthusiasts seeking a versatile and naturally sweet spread, the Musselmans Apple Butter (2 Pack, Total of 34oz) offers a delightful option without high fructose corn syrup. It's easy to spread on toast, pancakes, and even used in sandwiches. The product is well-loved for its ability to elevate various dishes.

Customers have enjoyed dipping chicken fingers or sweet potato fries in apple butter, adding it to smoothies or oatmeal, and combining it with peanut butter on crackers. However, some have encountered issues with packaging and leakage during shipping, which might be a concern for potential buyers.

Advertisement

Despite this, the overall feedback on the flavor has been very positive, with many noting its nostalgic and reminiscent taste. It's a product that brings the warmth of grandmother's kitchen to your breakfast table.

Best For: Breakfast enthusiasts looking for a naturally sweet and versatile spread without high fructose corn syrup.

Pros:

• Naturally sweet and versatile spread
• Can be used in a variety of dishes
• Nostalgic and reminiscent taste

Cons:

• Potential packaging and leakage issues during shipping

Musselmans Apple Butter

Musselmans Apple Butter offers a nostalgic taste of autumn and the holidays, making it an ideal breakfast spread for those seeking a comforting and familiar flavor experience. This well-known brand has been delighting taste buds for a long time, and its delicious spread can be enjoyed on toast, biscuits, oatmeal, waffles, and more.

Fans of the product have expressed their satisfaction, with one reviewer mentioning that it brought back childhood memories and made them feel like they were home again. Others have raved about its absolutely delicious taste and how quickly it disappeared from their pantry. Whether it's for breakfast or snacks, this apple butter is sure to add a delightful touch to your meals.

Advertisement

So, if you're looking for a delicious and versatile apple butter, Musselmans is definitely worth a try.

Best For: Those seeking a nostalgic and comforting flavor experience reminiscent of autumn and the holidays.

Pros:

• Versatile spread for breakfast and snacks
• Delightful taste that brings back childhood memories
• Well-known and trusted brand

Cons:

• Limited availability in some regions

Amish Valley Apple Butter in Glass Jar

The Amish Valley Apple Butter in Glass Jar is an ideal choice for those seeking a sweet and all-natural breakfast spread with a traditional homemade taste. Made in Ohio's Amish Country, this 16 oz glass jar contains a slow-cooked apple butter with a simple ingredient list including apples, sugar, apple juice concentrate, brown sugar, salt, spices, and citric acid.

Customers have praised its flavor and texture, making it a good option for gifting to teachers, hostesses, or friends. Some have found the jar size to be small and the price affordable. However, there have been packaging issues with jars arriving broken, prompting some customers to seek resolution from the company before reordering.

Advertisement

Overall, the Amish Valley Apple Butter offers a delightful taste of tradition, but potential buyers should be mindful of the packaging concerns.

Best For: Those looking for a sweet and traditional breakfast spread with an all-natural homemade taste.

Pros:

• Delicious flavor and texture
• Ideal for gifting to teachers, hostesses, or friends
• Affordable price for a small jar size

Cons:

• Potential packaging issues with jars arriving broken

McCutcheons Home Recipe Apple Butter, 19 ounces

McCutcheons Home Recipe Apple Butter, 19 ounces, offers a rich, mellow flavor that makes it a delightful choice for anyone seeking a natural and flavorful breakfast spread. Made in the USA since 1938, this apple butter is slow-cooked in small batches, ensuring a homemade taste. With all-natural ingredients and no high fructose corn sweeteners or preservatives, it's a wholesome option.

Lightly spiced with a hint of sweetness, it's perfect for spreading on toast, pancakes, or sandwiches, as well as using as a filling in cakes and donuts. Customers have praised its natural taste and smooth, easy-to-spread consistency.

Advertisement

McCutcheons, a family-owned business, has been producing premium foods for decades, and its wide range of farm-style favorites, including Cherry or Pumpkin Butter, Strawberry, and Peach or Blueberry Preserves, ensures there's something for everyone.

Best For: Apple lovers seeking a natural and flavorful breakfast spread with a homemade taste.

Pros:

• All-natural ingredients
• Slow-cooked in small batches
• Versatile use for spreading, filling, and gifting

Cons:

• Similar to cinnamon applesauce in consistency and flavor

Manischewitz Apple Butter, 17oz Smooth & Sweet Spread

For those seeking a naturally sweet and sugar-free breakfast spread, Manischewitz Apple Butter, 17oz Smooth & Sweet Spread offers a delicious and healthier option. Made with just two simple ingredients, this rich, dark brown sauce contains no added sugar, artificial flavors, or colors. It's a versatile product, perfect for spreading on toast, dipping biscuits, topping cakes, or adding to sauces and glazes for a sweet flavor.

Customers appreciate its deep, rich flavor and thick texture, along with its low calorie and carb content. While some find the price slightly high for the size of the jar, the large quantity of apple butter it contains makes up for it.

Advertisement

This product is a convenient choice for those looking for a sugar-free apple butter and can be easily purchased on Amazon.

Best For:

Health-conscious individuals seeking a naturally sweet and sugar-free breakfast spread.

Pros:

• No added sugar or artificial flavors
• Versatile for various recipes
• Low in calories and carbs

Cons:

• Slightly high price for the size of the jar

Amish Wedding All Natural Sugarless Apple Butter

With its delicious taste and natural juice sweetening, Amish Wedding All Natural Sugarless Apple Butter is an ideal choice for those seeking a low-carb and low-calorie breakfast spread. It's made in Holmes County, Ohio, and boasts a perfect consistency with no granulated sugars added.

Advertisement

This apple butter has received positive feedback for its enjoyable texture and flavor, with some customers suggesting the addition of extra spices for a personalized touch. While it's less sweet than regular apple butter, it's still a delightful option for spreading on toast, crackers, muffins, or even mixing into Greek yogurt.

As someone who grew up eating Apple Butter and Peanut Butter sandwiches, I'm happy to have found a sugarless option. After buying this product multiple times, I've decided to subscribe and keep it stocked in my kitchen pantry.

Best For: Health-conscious individuals looking for a low-carb, low-calorie, and sugarless apple butter option with natural sweetening.

Pros:

• Delicious taste with natural juice sweetening
• Low in carbs and calories
• Perfect consistency and enjoyable texture and flavor

Cons:

• Some customers may find it less sweet than regular apple butter

Tennessee's Best Old Fashion Style Apple Butter (16 oz Resealable Glass Jar)

Tennessee's Best Old Fashion Style Apple Butter is a handcrafted breakfast spread made with simple ingredients. Bursting with the flavor of fresh apples and spices, it offers a natural and robust taste. The apple butter comes in a 16 oz resealable glass jar, ensuring convenience and freshness. It has been praised for maintaining the flavor of the apples and spices, resulting in a slightly tart and very flavorful taste. While some customers have raised concerns about its freshness, the majority appreciate its unique, homemade flavor. Suggestions have been made for smaller containers to maintain freshness, as the current packaging is convenient but may impact the overall freshness of the product. Feedback from customers highlights the positive taste and flavor, although there are mixed opinions about its sweetness and price worthiness. If you appreciate natural and robust flavors and don't mind the potential freshness issue, Tennessee's Best Old Fashion Style Apple Butter could be a great addition to your breakfast table.

Advertisement

Best For: Those who appreciate natural and robust flavors and don't mind potential freshness issues.

Pros:

• Bursting with the flavor of fresh apples and spices
• Handcrafted with simple ingredients
• Slightly tart and very flavorful taste

Cons:

• Some customers found the freshness to be an issue

Musselmans Apple Butter 17 oz Jars (Pack of 3)

When seeking a breakfast spread with a rich, thick consistency and a delightful blend of apple, sugar, and spices, Musselmans Apple Butter 17 oz Jars (Pack of 3) stands out as a top choice. The product boasts positive customer reviews, indicating a strong satisfaction with its taste and texture.

However, it's important to note that there are challenges related to its availability in local stores, often necessitating reliance on online purchasing. While the cost might be higher compared to local stores, the convenience of online purchasing is a significant factor.

Users have expressed a personal connection to this apple butter, often citing childhood nostalgia and a longing for the product. Despite the limited availability and potentially higher cost, the overall quality and flavor make Musselmans Apple Butter 17 oz Jars a compelling option for breakfast spreads.

Advertisement

Best For: Breakfast enthusiasts looking for a rich and nostalgic apple spread with a thick consistency.

Pros:

• Rich and thick consistency
• Positive customer reviews
• Personal nostalgia and connection for many users

Cons:

• Limited availability in local stores

Cracker Barrel Spiced Apple Butter 28 oz

For those seeking a flavorful and authentic breakfast spread, the Cracker Barrel Spiced Apple Butter 28 oz offers a delightful and nostalgic touch to your morning meal. The positive reviews speak volumes about its quality, with many customers praising its excellent taste and likening it to homemade apple butter. It's a hit on biscuits and toast, and those who prefer a spiced flavor over plain apple butter will find this particularly appealing.

While some have noted a rise in price, the majority still consider it a great value and a worthwhile purchase. The only downside seems to be its availability, with some expressing disappointment about its limited in-store presence. Overall, the Cracker Barrel Spiced Apple Butter 28 oz seems to be a top contender for elevating your breakfast spread game.

Best For: Those who appreciate a high-quality, flavorful breakfast spread with a nostalgic homemade taste.

Advertisement

Pros:

• Excellent taste and quality, likened to homemade apple butter
• Great value and versatile usage on biscuits and toast
• Appealing spiced flavor preferred by many consumers

Cons:

• Price may be considered high by some customers

Redhawk Farms Apple Butter Fruit Spread (16 oz, Pack of 2)

Redhawk Farms Apple Butter Fruit Spread is a delectable, all-natural breakfast spread that caters to those seeking a homemade, sugar-free option with a rich, old-fashioned flavor. Made with simple ingredients like apples, sugar, apple juice concentrate, brown sugar, and spices, this slow-cooked apple butter is a delightful addition to any pantry. It's non-GMO, gluten-free, and free from artificial sweeteners, colors, or preservatives. Customers praise its homemade, old-fashioned style and appreciate its versatility. Whether spread on toast, drizzled over ice cream, or used in various dishes, this apple butter is a hit.

Packaged in a convenient 16 oz, Pack of 2, it's an ideal gift and a must-have for apple butter enthusiasts. Responsibly sourced and cooked in small batches in Ohio's Amish Country, it offers a premium, high-quality taste that keeps customers coming back for more.

Best For: Those seeking a versatile, all-natural, sugar-free breakfast spread with a rich, old-fashioned flavor.

Pros:

Advertisement

• Homemade, old-fashioned style
• Versatile use in various dishes
• Responsibly sourced, premium ingredients

Cons:

• Limited availability in some regions

Homestyle Apple Butter – One Pint – Grandmas Jam House

With its homestyle flavor and simple ingredients, Grandma's Jam House Homestyle Apple Butter is an ideal choice for those seeking a delicious and genuine breakfast spread. The one-pint glass jar, sealed with a screw-top lid, contains a delightful blend of apples, cider, cinnamon, sugar, and citric acid, providing a tangy and tart taste without being overly sweet. Made in the USA, this apple butter comes with a printed date indicating when it was made, ensuring freshness and quality.

Customer reviews praise its great taste and versatility, suggesting it as a perfect accompaniment to toast or as a delightful gift. With its simple and delicious taste, Grandma's Jam House Homestyle Apple Butter stands out as a premium choice for those looking for an authentic breakfast spread.

Best For: Breakfast enthusiasts looking for a tangy and tart apple spread with simple ingredients and a homemade flavor.

Pros:

• Versatile spread for toast, peanut butter, or gifting
• Tangy and tart taste without being overly sweet
• Made in the USA with simple and natural ingredients

Cons:

• Some customers may find the price relatively high for a 19 oz jar

Dillman Farm Organic No Sugar Added Apple Butter (13oz, Pack of 6)

Ideal for those seeking a guilt-free, low carb breakfast spread, the Dillman Farm Organic No Sugar Added Apple Butter provides a delicious, keto-friendly option with just two wholesome ingredients. This 6-pack of 13 oz. jars (78 oz. total) isn't only keto-friendly, gluten-free, and non-GMO but also vegan and kosher. Made in the USA in a Safe Quality Food Certified facility, it contains only organic apples and organic cinnamon, free from corn syrups, GMOs, or gluten.

Advertisement

With just 2 grams of carbs per tablespoon serving, it's a guilt-free treat for low carb diets and can be added to crepes, apple pie, parfaits, and keto protein shakes. Customers praise its delicious taste, versatility, and simple, pure organic ingredients. It's a thick and delicious option that can elevate your breakfast spread game.

Best For: Those following a low carb or keto lifestyle looking for a guilt-free and delicious breakfast spread option.

Pros:

• Keto-friendly, gluten-free, non-GMO, vegan, and kosher
• Made with only 2 organic ingredients: apples and cinnamon
• Versatile and can be used in various recipes and dishes

Cons:

• Some customers may find it less thick and flavorful than traditional apple butter

EDEN ORGANIC APPLE BUTTER 17 OZ

For those seeking a natural and wholesome breakfast spread option, the EDEN ORGANIC APPLE BUTTER 17 OZ offers a delicious choice made from a blend of organic apples, free from added sugar and preservatives. This apple butter isn't only organic but also macrobiotic, vegan, kosher, and gluten-free, catering to a wide range of dietary preferences. Customers rave about its fresh apple taste and commend its simple ingredients, containing no added sugar or citric acid, only apples. While some find the price to be a bit high, others appreciate the quality and are willing to pay for this organic, no sugar added product.

It's recommended to enhance the flavor by adding a sprinkle of cinnamon. Despite some packaging concerns, the overall consensus is that EDEN ORGANIC APPLE BUTTER 17 OZ is a top choice for a natural and flavorful breakfast spread.

Advertisement

Best For: Those seeking a natural and wholesome breakfast spread option that's organic, vegan, and free from added sugar.

Pros:

• Fresh apple taste with simple ingredients
• Organic, macrobiotic, vegan, kosher, and gluten-free
• Can be enhanced with a sprinkle of cinnamon

Cons:

• Some customers find the price to be high

Factors to Consider When Choosing Apple Butter

When choosing apple butter, we consider several factors such as taste and consistency, ingredients and quality, pricing and affordability, packaging and shipping, and usage ideas.

These points help us make an informed decision about which apple butter brand to buy for our breakfast spread. By considering these factors, we ensure that we choose the best apple butter that meets our preferences and needs.

Taste and Consistency

Considering the balance of sweetness and tartness is essential when choosing apple butter, as it directly impacts the overall taste and satisfaction of the spread. A delicious apple butter should offer a richly spiced flavor with a thick, jam-like consistency, making it easy to spread on toast.

Advertisement

It's important to find a product with a rich, mellow flavor and a hint of sweetness, without being overly sweet. Texture also plays a significant role, as some apple butters have a more applesauce-like consistency, while others are thick and flavorful. It's crucial to consider your preference for texture when making a selection.

Additionally, opting for apple butter that's low in sugar and free from added sweeteners can provide a healthier option without compromising on the sweet taste.

Ingredients and Quality

We prioritize selecting apple butter crafted with natural ingredients and without high fructose corn syrup, ensuring a quality spread with a homemade taste and rich, spiced flavor.

Quality apple butter is often hand-stirred in small batches, providing a thick, jam-like consistency.

Advertisement

It's important to pay attention to customer reviews to gauge overall satisfaction and feedback on the taste and quality of the apple butter.

Look for apple butter that can be used in a variety of ways, such as for spreading on breakfast breads, as a topping for desserts, or as an ingredient in recipes.

Additionally, consider the pricing and availability of the apple butter, and compare it to other brands or local options to ensure it aligns with your preferences.

Pricing and Affordability

To ensure a budget-friendly purchase, it's important to consider the price per unit and compare it with similar products for affordability. By calculating the cost per ounce or per serving, consumers can make informed decisions about the best value for their money.

Advertisement

Additionally, looking for options to buy in bulk or multi-packs can often result in cost savings. It's also beneficial to check for any available discounts, promotions, or coupons to save money on the purchase.

When evaluating the overall value for the price paid, factors such as quantity, quality, and ingredients should be taken into consideration.

Furthermore, considering the long-term affordability by assessing the frequency of use and shelf life of the product can help in making a well-informed and economical choice.

Packaging and Shipping

When selecting apple butter, it's crucial to prioritize well-packaged options that ensure the product arrives undamaged and maintains its freshness during shipping. Look for apple butter that's securely packaged to prevent leakage and breakage during transit.

Advertisement

It's also wise to check customer reviews for feedback on the packaging and shipping experience, including any issues encountered.

Additionally, consider the availability of the apple butter for shipping, especially if it's not readily accessible in local stores. Evaluate the shipping costs and delivery timeframes when purchasing apple butter online to make sure it aligns with your needs.

Usage Ideas

Consider pairing apple butter with savory dishes such as pork chops or roasted vegetables to add a touch of sweetness and depth of flavor. The rich, velvety texture of apple butter makes it a versatile ingredient, perfect for spreading on toast, biscuits, or muffins.

It can also be used as a glaze for meats like chicken or ham, adding a caramelized crust and a burst of fruity flavor. For a quick and easy snack, try swirling apple butter into yogurt or oatmeal.

Advertisement

It can even be incorporated into marinades and salad dressings to lend a hint of apple sweetness. Whether you're looking to elevate your breakfast spread or add a unique twist to your savory dishes, apple butter is a delicious and simple way to enhance your meals.

Customer Satisfaction

When choosing apple butter, we prioritize customer satisfaction by considering factors such as taste, quality, packaging, and overall experience.

Positive feedback about the rich, flavorful taste of apple butter indicates high customer satisfaction. Customers often mention the smooth texture, balanced sweetness, and natural ingredients when expressing their satisfaction with the product.

Additionally, reviews that highlight the high quality of the apple butter, its freshness, and the attractive, practical packaging also contribute to overall customer satisfaction. Repeat purchases and recommendations in customer comments reflect a positive overall experience, influencing satisfaction.

Advertisement

Furthermore, factors like pricing, availability, and shipping experience play a role in determining customer satisfaction. Therefore, we carefully consider customer feedback on taste, texture, freshness, pricing, availability, and the overall experience to gauge customer satisfaction when recommending apple butter brands.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Are the Nutritional Values and Ingredients of Each of the Apple Butter Brands Listed?

We'll provide the nutritional values and ingredients of each apple butter brand listed. It's important to consider both the nutritional content and ingredients to make informed choices.

Nutritional values can include calories, fat, sugar, and more. Ingredients may vary and can impact dietary preferences or restrictions. We'll detail these aspects for each brand, helping you make the best choice for your breakfast spread.

Are There Any Specific Recipes or Serving Suggestions for Using the Apple Butter in Different Dishes?

Advertisement

Sure, we've got some delicious ideas for using apple butter in various dishes.

You can spread it on toast or pancakes, swirl it into oatmeal, or use it as a glaze for roasted meats.

It's also fantastic in baked goods like muffins and cookies.

And don't forget to mix it into yogurt or blend it into smoothies for a tasty twist.

The possibilities are endless!

Advertisement

Can You Provide Information on the Sourcing and Production Process for the Apples Used in Each Brand's Apple Butter?

Sure, we can provide information on the sourcing and production process for the apples used in each brand's apple butter.

The apples are carefully selected from local orchards to ensure freshness and quality.

They undergo a meticulous production process, including washing, peeling, and cooking to achieve the perfect flavor and texture.

Our commitment to using high-quality apples and a detailed production process results in a delicious and premium apple butter.

Advertisement

Are There Any Unique or Special Flavors or Variations Available Within Each Brand's Apple Butter Product Line?

Sure, there are unique flavors and variations in each brand's apple butter.

Some offer traditional apple butter with added spices like cinnamon or nutmeg, while others have creative twists like adding in other fruits or spirits for a special kick.

It's exciting to see the diverse options available, and I'm sure there's something to suit every taste bud and elevate your breakfast spread game.

Can You Offer Any Tips for Storing and Preserving Apple Butter Once It Has Been Opened?

Advertisement

Once opened, we usually store apple butter in the refrigerator to keep it fresh for longer.

It's important to use a clean, airtight container to maintain its flavor and prevent spoilage.

We recommend consuming the apple butter within a few weeks of opening for the best taste.

If you have leftover apple butter, consider freezing it in small portions for future use.

This helps to preserve its quality and extend its shelf life.

Advertisement

Conclusion

In conclusion, when it comes to choosing the best apple butter brands, it's important to consider factors such as taste, texture, and ingredients. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to make a decision.

But did you know that the average American consumes about 1.5 pounds of apple butter each year? So, whether you prefer a traditional or organic option, there's a perfect apple butter out there to elevate your breakfast spread game.

Jamie

From sneaky childhood butter licks to penning some of our most popular articles, Jamie’s journey with butter has been lifelong. His culinary background gives him a unique perspective, allowing him to craft mouthwatering articles that educate and tantalize equally. Jamie’s travel adventures revolve around finding the world’s best buttery treats when he isn’t writing.