15 Best All-Natural Peanut Butters You Need to Try in 2025

If you’re looking for the best all-natural peanut butter options in 2025, I have compiled a list of 15 top picks! From Skippy’s creamy goodness to Smuckers’ organic blend and Teddie’s super chunky delight, there is a spread to suit every taste. Be sure to try Jif’s sweet twist with honey or the delicious Once Again varieties available in bulk. When selecting, consider factors such as nutrition, ingredient transparency, texture, consistency, and packaging quality. It is important to also keep in mind eco-friendly options and price comparisons to make the best choice for your peanut butter cravings. Indulge in the delicious world of natural peanut butter bliss!

Key Takeaways

• Look for brands with real roasted peanuts, no trans fats, and diverse textures like creamy or crunchy.
• Prioritize ingredient transparency: no added sugars, artificial additives, or questionable sourcing.
• Consider packaging quality: sturdy, airtight containers with eco-friendly options.
• Evaluate price per ounce for cost-effectiveness, including bulk and organic choices.
• Take into account customer feedback on taste, quality, consistency, and overall value.

Skippy Natural Peanut Butter, Creamy, 26.5 oz

For those seeking a creamy and flavorful all-natural peanut butter option in 2025, Skippy Natural Peanut Butter is the ideal choice. This 26.5 oz jar is filled with real roasted peanuts, boasting a total of four simple ingredients.

Each serving packs a punch with 7 grams of protein and 0 grams of trans-fat. What sets this peanut butter apart is its commitment to quality – no added preservatives, artificial flavors, or colors.

In addition, it caters to various dietary needs being certified Kosher, gluten-free, and tree nut-free. Skippy Natural Peanut Butter comes in a range of options like Chunky, Creamy, Reduced Fat, and even SUPER CHUNK spread, providing versatility for all preferences.

Trust the brand that has been delivering since 1933 for a nutritious and delicious peanut butter experience.

Best For: Health-conscious individuals looking for a natural and versatile peanut butter option without added preservatives.

Pros:

• Made with real roasted peanuts and only four simple ingredients
• High protein content and zero trans-fat per serving
• Certified Kosher, gluten-free, and tree nut-free for dietary preferences

Cons:

• May be pricier compared to conventional peanut butter brands
• Limited availability in certain stores or regions
• Some users may prefer a smoother consistency than the creamy texture

Smuckers Organic Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 Ounces (Pack of 1)

Ideal for health-conscious consumers seeking a creamy and organic peanut butter option, the Smuckers Organic Natural Creamy Peanut Butter in a 16-ounce jar is a standout choice in the 'All-Natural Peanut Butters for 2025'. Made with only organic roasted peanuts and a touch of salt, this product boasts zero grams of trans fat per serving.

Customers praise its taste, texture, and simple ingredients, recommending stirring before use and refrigeration to prevent separation. While some caution about potential texture changes over time, many appreciate its health benefits, like being free from added sugars and palm oil.

With a Best Sellers Rank of #55,826 in Grocery & Gourmet Food and #262 in Peanut Butter, this option has gained popularity for those looking for a natural and wholesome peanut butter choice.

Best For: Health-conscious consumers seeking a natural and creamy organic peanut butter option with simple ingredients.

Pros:

• Made with organic roasted peanuts and minimal salt, providing a healthier choice.
• Zero grams of trans fat per serving, appealing to those focused on wholesome nutrition.
• Appreciated for its taste, texture, and lack of added sugars or palm oil.

Cons:

• Potential texture changes over time may affect spreadability.
• Concerns about packaging quality and potential leakage issues.
• Some users experienced issues with the refund process due to packaging issues.

Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, Super Chunky

With its gluten-free and vegan composition, Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, Super Chunky is a top pick for health-conscious individuals seeking a simple ingredient list without sacrificing taste. This American-made peanut butter contains 100% fresh roasted and ground USA-grown peanuts, processed to strict quality specifications.

Teddie has maintained an impeccable record with no outbreaks or recalls in over 87 years of business. The crunchy texture of this peanut butter, made solely from peanuts and salt without any added sugar, has garnered praise from customers for its great taste and quality.

While some find the need for stirring a minor inconvenience, the overall consensus is that Teddie Peanut Butter offers a delicious and affordable option for those looking for a healthier, all-natural spread.

Best For: Health-conscious individuals seeking a simple ingredient list without sacrificing taste.

Pros:

• Made from 100% fresh roasted and ground USA-grown peanuts
• Gluten-free and vegan option
• Affordable and delicious compared to other brands

Cons:

• Requires stirring
• Some customers wish for larger jar sizes
• Limited variety in terms of flavor options

SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, No Sugar Added, 40 oz jar

The SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, No Sugar Added, 40 oz jar is a top pick for health-conscious individuals seeking a simple, natural snack option with a rich peanut flavor. This peanut butter is made with just three ingredients: peanuts, palm oil, and salt, offering a protein-packed treat with 7g of protein per serving.

It contains real roasted peanuts without added preservatives, making it a wholesome choice. Free from artificial flavors or colors, gluten, and tree nuts, it caters to various dietary needs.

With a creamy texture that spreads easily on toast, this peanut butter is a versatile option for sandwiches, no bake buckeye bars, or simply enjoying on its own. SKIPPY's No Sugar Added spread has garnered positive feedback for its taste, texture, and lower sugar content, making it a popular choice among those looking to reduce sugar intake.

Best For: Health-conscious individuals looking for a natural, low-sugar peanut butter option with a creamy texture and rich peanut flavor.

Pros:

• Made with only three simple ingredients: peanuts, palm oil, and salt
• Contains 7g of protein per serving
• Suitable for various dietary needs, free from artificial flavors, colors, gluten, and tree nuts

Cons:

• Requires stirring before use due to separation
• May not be suitable for those with peanut allergies
• Limited flavor options compared to other peanut butter brands

Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread and Honey, 16 Ounces

For those craving a flavorful blend of peanuts and honey in their spread, Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread and Honey, 16 Ounces offers a delectable and convenient option without the need for stirring.

This 16-ounce jar packs a punch with 80% peanuts and a touch of honey, delivering a low-sodium spread with 7g of protein per serving.

Free from preservatives and gluten, this peanut butter boasts an irresistible taste that's sure to please any palate.

Simply open the jar, spread it on your favorite snack, and enjoy the delicious and nutritious flavors.

With Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread and Honey, you get the perfect blend of nutty goodness and sweet honey, making it a top choice for those looking for a delicious twist on traditional peanut butter spreads.

Best For: Peanut butter enthusiasts looking for a flavorful blend of peanuts and honey in a convenient spread without the hassle of stirring.

Pros:

• Made with 80% peanuts and a touch of honey for a delectable taste
• Low sodium content and 7g of protein per serving
• No preservatives and gluten-free for a clean and natural option

Cons:

• Contains honey, which may not be suitable for individuals with honey allergies
• Limited to those who enjoy the combination of peanuts and honey in their spreads
• May not be ideal for those seeking a traditional plain peanut butter option

Justins Peanut Butter Honey Jar, 16 Oz

Ideal for those seeking a versatile and natural peanut butter option, Justins Peanut Butter Honey Jar, 16 Oz offers a delicious honey peanut butter flavor with no artificial ingredients or refined sugar. This all-natural product boasts a short list of healthy ingredients, making it a good value for those looking for a healthier alternative.

Customers have praised its great taste and smooth consistency, highlighting its suitability for baking or enjoying straight from the jar without the need for messy stirring. It has received positive feedback for its quality and taste, appealing to individuals of all ages.

Justins Peanut Butter Honey Jar is a popular choice for those looking for a stable, flavorful peanut butter option that can be used in various ways, such as on bread, in smoothies, or even in savory recipes like pad thai.

Best For: Those looking for a natural, no-stir peanut butter option with a delicious honey peanut butter flavor.

Pros:

• No artificial ingredients or refined sugar
• Suitable for baking or enjoying straight from the jar
• Great taste and smooth consistency

Cons:

• Some customers found the flavor lacking and texture strange
• Expiry date concerns for some customers
• Some discrepancies in labeling between Amazon and actual product

Peanut Butter & Co. Simply Crunchy Peanut Butter (Pack of 3)

When looking for a natural peanut butter option with simple, non-GMO ingredients and a crunchy texture, Peanut Butter & Co. Simply Crunchy Peanut Butter (Pack of 3) is a top choice. This product is Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, and vegan, making it suitable for a variety of dietary preferences.

Each 16-ounce jar in the pack of 3 is made with honest ingredients, providing 7g of protein per serving with 0g trans fat and no cholesterol. Whether spread on sandwiches, paired with fruit, used in recipes, or enjoyed straight from the jar, this peanut butter offers a delicious and versatile option.

While some customers have noted mixed reviews on taste, texture, and consistency, overall feedback leans towards positive, highlighting its flavor and quality.

Best For: Individuals looking for a natural peanut butter option with simple, non-GMO ingredients and a crunchy texture.

Pros:

• Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, and vegan
• 7g of protein per serving with 0g trans fat and no cholesterol
• Versatile usage options including spreading, mixing, and enjoying straight from the jar

Cons:

• Mixed reviews on taste, texture, and consistency
• Some concerns about watery consistency and separation
• Pricing considerations and comparisons with other natural peanut butter brands

MaraNatha Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 Ounce Jar

The MaraNatha Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, in a 16-ounce jar, is a top choice for those seeking a USDA-certified organic and non-GMO peanut butter with a touch of sea salt for enhanced flavor. This peanut butter is free from artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives, making it a wholesome option for peanut butter enthusiasts.

It has received praise for its creamy texture, easy spreadability, and delicious taste, making it a versatile option for dipping, spreading, and classic PB&J sandwiches. Some customers have expressed concerns about the plastic jar affecting the product's consistency and taste, preferring the previous glass jar with a metal lid for maintaining quality.

To prevent runniness, it's recommended to store this peanut butter in the fridge after opening and to stir if oil separation occurs.

Best For: Those looking for a USDA-certified organic and non-GMO creamy peanut butter with a touch of sea salt for enhanced flavor.

Pros:

• Creamy texture and easy spreadability
• Delicious taste with a touch of sea salt
• Versatile for dipping, spreading, and PB&J sandwiches

Cons:

• Plastic jar concerns affecting product consistency and taste
• Some customers disappointed with palm oil and sugar content
• Preference for pure peanut butter without additives

Peter Pan Honey Roast Creamy Peanut Butter (Pack of 3)

For those seeking a creamy and subtly sweet peanut butter option, the Peter Pan Honey Roast Creamy Peanut Butter (Pack of 3) offers a delightful choice within the domain of all-natural peanut butters for 2025.

This product, branded by Peter Pan, comes in 16.3oz jars in a pack of three. Customer reviews are generally positive, praising the taste and quality, though some express concerns about packaging issues and pricing compared to other retailers.

The experiences with this peanut butter are varied, with some customers declaring it as their favorite and others feeling let down. Some customers have faced difficulties finding it in local stores, leading them to purchase it online. Comparisons with other Peter Pan varieties such as Creamy Whipped and price checks between Amazon and Walmart have been noted.

Additionally, there have been instances of customers requesting refunds due to dissatisfaction, especially regarding damaged packaging and discrepancies between labeling and ingredients.

Best For: Individuals looking for a creamy and subtly sweet all-natural peanut butter option that offers a delightful taste experience.

Pros:

• Delightful taste with a subtle sweetness
• Good quality peanut butter
• Suitable for those who prefer creamy textures

Cons:

• Packaging issues reported by some customers
• Pricing concerns compared to other retailers
• Mixed customer experiences, leading to potential disappointment

Justins Classic Peanut Butter Squeeze Packs

With its gluten-free, non-GMO, and vegan attributes, Justins Classic Peanut Butter Squeeze Packs are a convenient and nutritious choice for health-conscious individuals on-the-go. These packs are made with only two ingredients and are responsibly sourced, ensuring a high-quality product.

Available in various flavors, Justins Classic Peanut Butter Squeeze Packs are packed with protein, gluten-free, non-GMO, and contain 0g trans fat, making them a wholesome snack option. The unique grinding process used to make these squeeze packs merges great taste, texture, and nutrition in a mess-free and easy-to-squeeze package.

While some customers have noted concerns about package integrity and pricing, the overall feedback is positive, highlighting the taste and convenience of these squeeze packs for high-protein snacking, backpacking, or everyday breakfast.

Best For: Individuals looking for a convenient and nutritious on-the-go snack option with gluten-free, non-GMO, and vegan attributes.

Pros:

• Made with only two ingredients and responsibly sourced
• Packed with protein, gluten-free, non-GMO, and 0g trans fat
• Easy-to-squeeze and mess-free packaging, perfect for traveling

Cons:

• Some concerns about package integrity and pricing
• Mixed opinions on taste and texture, with some finding it gritty
• Not economical for daily use, but great for lightweight needs

MaraNatha Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter Spread, No Stir, 16 Ounce Jar

Ideal for health-conscious individuals seeking a flavorful and organic peanut butter option, MaraNatha Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter Spread stands out for its natural ingredients and convenient no-stir feature. This 16-ounce jar contains a rich peanut flavor with roasted pieces for added crunch.

Being USDA Certified Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, and Kosher (OU Parve), it aligns with various dietary preferences. Customer reviews praise its creamy texture, great flavor, and nutritional value, making it a versatile choice for spreading or using in recipes. However, some users express disappointment with the new plastic jar design and the presence of palm oil and cane sugar.

To maintain consistency, consider storing it in the fridge as plastic jars may affect taste and texture negatively.

Best For: Health-conscious individuals looking for a flavorful and organic peanut butter option with convenient no-stir feature.

Pros:

• Rich peanut flavor with roasted pieces for added crunch
• Creamy texture and great flavor
• USDA Certified Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, and Kosher (OU Parve)

Cons:

• Disappointment with the new plastic jar design
• Presence of palm oil and cane sugar may not align with certain preferences
• Plastic jars may affect taste and texture negatively

Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 9lb Bucket (Same as 9 Jars)

The Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter in a 9lb Bucket is a convenient and cost-effective option for households that frequently consume peanut butter. This product, equivalent to 9 jars, is made solely from roasted and ground blanched, dry roasted peanuts without any added salt or sweeteners.

Sourced ethically from Nicaragua, Argentina, and the USA, it holds certifications for being Gluten-Free, Vegan, Kosher, and Non-GMO Verified. Customer reviews generally praise its delicious taste and natural quality, with some suggesting refrigeration to maintain consistency.

While most appreciate the container design and lack of separation issues, a few note concerns about hardened peanut butter at the bottom. Despite some mixed experiences, the 9lb Bucket offers value for families seeking a bulk purchase of high-quality peanut butter.

Best For: Families or individuals who consume peanut butter regularly and prefer a natural, unsweetened, and salt-free option in bulk.

Pros:

• Made from ethically sourced peanuts with certifications for being Gluten-Free, Vegan, Kosher, and Non-GMO Verified.
• Convenient 9lb bucket equivalent to 9 jars, offering cost-effectiveness and value for frequent peanut butter consumers.
• Positive customer reviews on taste and quality, with some recommending refrigeration for consistency.

Cons:

• Some concerns raised about hardened peanut butter at the bottom of the bucket, potentially due to prolonged storage.
• Mixed customer experiences with taste and consistency, suggesting variations in individual preferences.
• Requires immediate mixing upon receiving to prevent settling, which may inconvenience some users.

Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 5lb Pantry Pal

For those seeking a bulk supply of creamy, all-natural peanut butter without added sugars, Once Again Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 5lb Pantry Pal offers a convenient option. This 5-pound bucket contains a blend of blanched, dry roasted peanuts sourced ethically from Nicaragua, Argentina, and the USA. Lightly salted and unsweetened, this peanut butter is Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, and Non-GMO Verified.

While no preservatives are added, it's recommended to refrigerate after opening to minimize oil separation. Customers appreciate the freshness and bulk size, though some find the consistency a bit oily and average in taste. This product is versatile, suitable for crackers, sandwiches, or post-workout energy boosts. However, a few users have expressed a desire for easier stirring due to occasional oil separation issues.

Best For: Individuals looking for a bulk supply of all-natural, unsweetened, and lightly salted creamy peanut butter without added sugars.

Pros:

• Ethically sourced peanuts from Nicaragua, Argentina, and the USA
• Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified
• Freshness and bulk size appreciated by customers

Cons:

• Some users find the consistency a bit oily and average in taste
• Occasional oil separation issues may require stirring before use
• Shelf life of three months once opened

Once Again Organic Creamy Peanut Butter – 1.15oz Squeeze Packs, 10 Count

Ethically sourced from Nicaragua, Argentina, and the USA, the Once Again Organic Creamy Peanut Butter in 1.15oz Squeeze Packs, 10 Count, is a top choice for individuals seeking a convenient, on-the-go snack option with no added sugars or salts. Made from roasted, ground peanuts, this peanut butter is USDA Organic, Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, Vegan, and Kosher Certified, catering to various dietary preferences.

Customers appreciate its simplicity and rich peanut taste without excessive sweetness. The convenient packaging makes it ideal for lunch boxes, backpacks, hiking, or travel. While some concerns about packaging quality during delivery have been raised, overall satisfaction with the product's quality and taste remains high.

With positive feedback on taste, quality, and ease of use, many individuals are inclined to repurchase for their snacking needs.

Best For: Individuals looking for a convenient, healthy, and on-the-go snack option without added sugars or salts.

Pros:

• Ethically sourced ingredients from multiple countries
• Convenient single-serve squeeze packs for easy snacking
• Versatile and suitable for various dietary preferences

Cons:

• Some concerns about packaging quality and handling during delivery
• Limited flavor options available
• May be more expensive compared to traditional peanut butter jars

Once Again Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter, 16oz

When seeking a crunchy peanut butter free from added salt or sweeteners, Once Again Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter, 16oz, sourced from Nicaragua, Argentina, and the USA, is a top choice for those prioritizing quality and ethical ingredients.

This peanut butter is made with roasted and ground blanched, dry roasted peanuts, offering a natural and pure taste without any additional additives. Certified Gluten Free, Vegan, Kosher, and Non-GMO Verified, it caters to various dietary preferences.

However, some customers have raised concerns about its pricing compared to local options. Additionally, there have been reports of broken jars during shipping and challenges in obtaining refunds for damaged products.

Despite these issues, the positive feedback on the taste and crunchiness of Once Again Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter keeps customers coming back for more.

Best For: Those seeking a natural and ethically sourced crunchy peanut butter without added salt or sweeteners.

Pros:

• Made with roasted and ground blanched, dry roasted peanuts for a natural and pure taste.
• Certified Gluten Free, Vegan, Kosher, and Non-GMO Verified, catering to various dietary preferences.
• Positive feedback on taste and crunchiness, appealing to those prioritizing quality.

Cons:

• Relatively expensive compared to local alternatives.
• Reports of broken jars during shipping and challenges in obtaining refunds for damaged products.
• Some customers find issues with the pricing and packaging compared to other peanut butter brands.

Factors to Consider When Choosing All Natural Peanut Butter

When selecting all-natural peanut butter, it's important to weigh key factors like:

• Nutritional content
• Ingredient transparency
• Texture
• Consistency
• Packaging quality

These elements can impact the overall taste and experience of the product, ensuring you choose one that aligns with your preferences and dietary needs. By examining these aspects closely, you can make an informed decision that satisfies both your taste buds and health goals.

Key Choosing Factors

When selecting all-natural peanut butter, prioritizing minimal ingredients and quality certifications is essential. Opt for peanut butter that contains only peanuts and perhaps salt, avoiding unnecessary additives.

Look for reputable certifications like USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, and Kosher, which guarantee higher quality standards in the product.

Consider your preference for texture, whether smooth or crunchy, and how easily the peanut butter spreads. If you prefer a pure peanut butter option, check the label for additional ingredients like sugar, palm oil, or preservatives.

Packaging also plays a role in maintaining freshness and preventing oil separation; choose options like glass jars or no-stir formulas for a better experience.

Nutritional Content

To make an informed choice when selecting all-natural peanut butter, one must consider the nutritional content, focusing on factors like protein, healthy fats, carbohydrates, and the absence of added sugars or preservatives.

All-natural peanut butter is a rich source of protein, typically providing around 7-8 grams per serving. It also contains beneficial healthy fats, including monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats, which are essential for a well-rounded diet.

Moreover, natural peanut butter is generally low in carbohydrates, making it a suitable choice for individuals following low-carb or keto diets.

When choosing a peanut butter, it's essential to opt for options with no added sugars or preservatives to ensure a clean and healthy product. Check the ingredient list carefully, aiming for products that contain only peanuts and perhaps salt, while avoiding added oils or artificial flavors.

Ingredient Transparency

For those seeking all-natural peanut butter, prioritizing ingredient transparency is crucial in making an well-informed choice. When selecting a brand, look for products that provide full disclosure of ingredients, ideally listing only peanuts and possibly salt.

Avoid options that sneak in added sugars, palm oil, hydrogenated oils, or artificial additives, as these can compromise the purity and health benefits of the peanut butter. It's also wise to opt for brands that clearly indicate the sourcing of their peanuts to secure ethical and quality standards are met.

Organic and non-GMO verified peanut butter varieties offer a cleaner and more environmentally friendly option. Additionally, consider peanut butter packaged in glass jars or recyclable materials to lessen environmental impact and preserve product freshness.

Texture and Consistency

Considering the variety of textures and consistencies available, selecting the ideal all-natural peanut butter involves evaluating personal preferences and desired spreadability. Natural peanut butter can range from smooth and creamy to chunky and crunchy. Some varieties may need stirring to mix in separated oil, while others are no-stir for convenience. The texture of these peanut butters is influenced by factors such as the roasting process and any additional ingredients present.

Creamy peanut butter offers a smoother and easier spread, while chunky types contain visible peanut pieces for added texture. Consistency is pivotal in determining the overall mouthfeel and satisfaction of the peanut butter, catering to individual preferences for thickness and spreadability.

Whether you prefer your peanut butter silky smooth or packed with crunchy bits, there's a natural option out there to suit your taste and texture preferences.

Packaging Quality

When choosing all-natural peanut butter, one must pay attention to the quality of the packaging to guarantee freshness and integrity of the product. Quality packaging plays a vital role in maintaining the flavor and consistency of the peanut butter. Opt for sturdy containers like glass jars or durable plastic to prevent leaks and preserve the product.

Airtight seals and secure lids are vital in preventing oxidation and retaining the rich taste of the peanut butter. Transparent or labeled packaging provides valuable information on ingredients, certifications, and expiration dates, aiding in making an informed choice.

Additionally, eco-friendly packaging options, such as using recyclable materials, not only contribute to sustainability but also reflect a brand's commitment to environmental responsibility. By considering the packaging quality when selecting your all-natural peanut butter, you can ensure a delightful and fresh peanut butter experience while also supporting sustainable practices in the food industry.

Price and Value

I always prioritize evaluating the price and value of all-natural peanut butter options before making a purchase decision.

When considering cost-effectiveness, it's important to look at the price per ounce. Opting for bulk purchases or multi-packs can often lead to savings on larger quantities.

Additionally, comparing organic and non-organic options can help determine the best value for your preferences and budget. Keep an eye out for any extra costs like shipping fees or membership requirements that may impact the overall price.

It's vital to assess the quality of ingredients and production methods in relation to the price to make sure you're getting your money's worth.

Conclusion

To wrap things up, when it comes to selecting all-natural peanut butter, there are plenty of tasty options to explore. Did you know that the average American consumes about 3 pounds of peanut butter each year?

So why not ensure you're savoring the highest quality and flavor by experimenting with some of the top picks mentioned in this article. Happy spreading!