The best donut baking pans balance easy release with dependable handling and a cavity count that suits the batches you make. My best overall pick is the Wilton Gold Non-Stick Donut Pan Set, which pairs two pans with a stated PFAS-free coating; for larger batches, the LYNCHAOXAN 24-cavity set offers the most wells in this lineup. If you prefer flexible bakeware, the KASHME silicone pans with metal frames address a common silicone drawback: awkward, floppy transfers. The main tradeoffs are metal’s firmer support versus silicone’s flexibility, along with pan capacity, storage space, coating care, and the number of batches you need to bake. Read on for the full comparison, selection criteria, and advice on matching a pan to your kitchen.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- Wilton’s two-pan set is my best overall choice: its stated PFAS-free coating and two-piece format make it a balanced pick for regular home baking, while buyers who need the highest stated capacity can look to LYNCHAOXAN’s 24 cavities.
- Batch size changes the shortlist: the 12-cavity Chefmade, Yumatouch, and HAPPIELS pans can bake more at once than six-cavity options, while paired six-cavity pans offer separate-pan flexibility.
- Silicone is not automatically easier to handle: KASHME and the framed silicone option address stability with metal support, while flexible molds without a frame call for careful transport.
- The lineup’s materials serve different priorities: carbon steel and aluminized steel give a rigid shape, while silicone favors flexibility; buyers should weigh handling and care preferences rather than assume one material bakes better in every oven.
- Stated details are uneven across listings: NutriChef specifies oven use up to 450°F, and Wilton identifies its coating as made without PFAS, but many products do not state comparable temperature or coating details in their names.
| donut baking pan | Material | Brand |
|---|---|---|
| HONGBAKE Donut Pan for Baking | Carbon steel | HONGBAKE |
| Vnray Nonstick Silicone Donut | BPA-free food-grade silicone with metal frame | Vnray |
| Chefmade Donut Mold Cake Pan | Carbon steel with food-grade silicone nonstick coating | CHEFMADE |
| Bellemain Nonstick Donut Pan f | Stainless steel | — |
| KASHME 3-Inch Silicone Donut P | BPA-free silicone with metal frame | KASHME |
| Walfos Silicone Nonstick Donut | Food-grade silicone | — |
| Bake Choice 6-Cavity Carbon St | Carbon steel | — |
| LYNCHAOXAN 2-Pack Nonstick Car | Carbon steel | — |
| YOVLOSIN 2-Pack Nonstick Donut | Carbon steel | — |
| Yumatouch 12-Cavity Nonstick C | Carbon steel | — |
| Wilton Gold Non-Stick Donut Pa | Stainless steel | Wilton |
| HAPPIELS 12-Well Nonstick Donu | High-carbon steel | HAPPIELS |
| Large Silicone Donut Pan for B | BPA-free food-grade silicone | FUNLAVIE |
| NutriChef Nonstick Donut Pan | Carbon steel with nonstick silicone coating | — |
| USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized St | Aluminized steel | USA Pan |
More Details on Our Top Picks
HONGBAKE Donut Pan for Baking – 2-Pack Nonstick Carbon Steel Deep Donut Molds (6 Cavities Each)
The HONGBAKE two-pan set is the clearest pick here for bakers who want thicker cake-style donuts rather than a shallower ring. Its deeper 2.8-inch cavities give batter more room, while carbon steel is designed to spread heat evenly and resist warping. With 12 cavities across two pans, you can bake a dozen at once; the single-pan Chefmade, by comparison, also has 12 cavities but takes up one larger pan footprint. The nonstick coating should help with release, though I’d follow the hand-wash recommendation rather than rely on its listed dishwasher-safe status. Its 450°F ceiling is higher than Chefmade’s 428°F limit, but still rules it out for recipes requiring hotter oven settings. Choose it for deeper donuts and batch capacity, not for minimal cleanup.
Pros:- Two pans provide 12 cavities for baking a dozen donuts in one batch.
- Deeper 2.8-inch cavities suit fuller cake-style donuts.
- Carbon steel construction is designed for even heat distribution and resistance to warping.
- Nonstick coating supports easier donut release.
Cons:- Hand washing is recommended to protect the nonstick coating.
- The 450°F maximum limits recipes that call for hotter oven settings.
Best for: Home bakers making a dozen thicker, cake-style donuts at a time who want two pans for easier batch handling.
Not ideal for: Bakers who prioritize dishwasher cleaning or need bakeware rated above 450°F.
- Brand:HONGBAKE
- Material:Carbon steel
- Pack:2 pans
- Cavities:6 per pan; 12 total
- Pan dimensions:11 x 7.5 x 1.18 inches
- Cavity diameter:2.8 inches
- Maximum oven temperature:450°F
- Warranty:10 years
Our verdict“Choose the HONGBAKE set if deeper cake-style donuts and two-pan capacity matter more than dishwasher convenience.”
Vnray Nonstick Silicone Donut Pan – 3.5-Inch Doughnut Baking Mold with Frame
The Vnray silicone pans stand apart for their 3.5-inch donut holes, larger than the 3-inch KASHME set and the 2.8-inch HONGBAKE cavities. That size makes this a better fit for bakers who want more substantial portions from a flexible mold. The included metal frame helps keep the pan supported during the trip to the oven, addressing a common handling drawback of silicone. The tradeoff is that the cavities still benefit from a light coat of oil, while the carbon-steel Chefmade offers a more rigid pan body and is listed as dishwasher safe. Vnray is rated to 446°F and freezer safe to -40°C, giving it useful temperature range for baking and frozen preparations. Pick it for larger silicone-formed donuts, not if you want the firm feel of steel.
Pros:- 3.5-inch holes make larger donuts than the 3-inch KASHME cavities.
- Metal frame supports the flexible mold during transfer.
- BPA-free food-grade silicone is rated for oven and freezer use.
- Nonstick surface supports release when lightly oiled.
Cons:- A thin layer of oil is recommended for best release.
- Hand washing is recommended to help preserve the silicone pan.
- Silicone does not provide the rigid feel of the carbon-steel Chefmade pan.
Best for: Bakers who prefer flexible silicone molds and want larger 3.5-inch donuts with a supported transfer frame.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want an all-metal pan, minimal preparation before filling, or dishwasher-focused cleanup.
- Brand:Vnray
- Material:BPA-free food-grade silicone with metal frame
- Pack:2 pans
- Cavities:6 per pan
- Pan dimensions:13.8 x 8.6 x 1.3 inches
- Hole diameter:3.5 inches
- Oven temperature limit:446°F
- Freezer temperature limit:-40°C
Our verdict“Pick Vnray if you want larger donuts from framed silicone molds and are comfortable oiling and hand washing them.”
Chefmade Donut Mold Cake Pan, 12-Cavity Non-Stick Ring Doughnut Bakeware (Champagne Gold)
For a baker who wants a dozen donuts in one pan, the Chefmade 12-cavity mold avoids managing a two-pan set like the HONGBAKE. Its 0.8 mm carbon-steel body is built for a stable, even-baking base, and the PTFE- and PFOA-free silicone coating is intended to release donuts with little oil. The listed dishwasher-safe cleanup is an advantage over both silicone sets here, whose care guidance favors hand washing. The tradeoffs are a lower 428°F heat limit than HONGBAKE’s 450°F rating and a relatively heavy 1.7-pound pan. Its dedicated donut shape also offers less flexibility than a mold that can serve other kitchen projects. I’d choose it for one-pan batch baking and a stated coating formulation, not for higher-heat recipes or multipurpose bakeware.
Pros:- Twelve cavities fit in one pan, unlike the two-pan HONGBAKE set.
- Thick 0.8 mm carbon steel is designed for even heat distribution.
- Food-grade silicone coating is listed as PTFE- and PFOA-free.
- Listed as dishwasher safe.
Cons:- The 428°F oven limit is lower than HONGBAKE’s 450°F rating.
- At 1.7 pounds, the pan may feel heavy to handle.
- Its dedicated donut mold shape offers limited use for other baking.
Best for: Families and frequent batch bakers who want 12 donut cavities in one rigid pan and value the stated PTFE- and PFOA-free coating.
Not ideal for: Bakers who need oven settings above 428°F, a lightweight pan, or bakeware for uses beyond donuts.
- Brand:CHEFMADE
- Material:Carbon steel with food-grade silicone nonstick coating
- Cavities:12
- Pan dimensions:12.8 x 10.2 x 0.91 inches
- Weight:1.7 pounds
- Maximum oven temperature:428°F
- Coating:PTFE- and PFOA-free
- Dishwasher safe:Yes
Our verdict“Choose Chefmade for one-pan, 12-donut batches and listed dishwasher-safe care, provided 428°F is enough for your recipes.”
Bellemain Nonstick Donut Pan for Baking, 6-Cavity Stainless Steel – 2 Pack
The Bellemain two-pack is the option in this group explicitly described for both donuts and bagels, giving it a more defined use beyond donut-only molds such as the Chefmade. Stainless steel construction and a nonstick coating make it a distinct alternative to the carbon-steel HONGBAKE, which offers deeper donut cups and a higher stated oven limit. Bellemain supplies 12 cavities across two pans, but only six are available on each pan, so it does not match Chefmade’s single-pan 12-cavity layout. The main compromise is care: these pans are hand wash only, while Chefmade is listed as dishwasher safe. The supplied dimensions are 12.5 x 8.5 x 3 inches, but no oven-temperature limit is provided, so I would not choose it for a recipe that depends on a specific heat rating.
Pros:- Two six-cavity pans provide 12 cavities across the set.
- Stainless steel construction offers an alternative to the carbon-steel pans.
- Nonstick coating is intended to ease release and cleanup.
- The product is described for baking both donuts and bagels.
Cons:- Hand washing is required; the pans are not listed as dishwasher safe.
- Each pan holds only six cavities, unlike the single-pan Chefmade.
- No oven-temperature limit is provided in the supplied product data.
Best for: Home bakers who want a two-pan set for small donut batches and also plan to bake bagels in the same molds.
Not ideal for: Bakers seeking dishwasher-safe pans, a single-pan dozen capacity, or a specified oven-temperature rating.
- Material:Stainless steel
- Coating:Nonstick
- Pack:2 pans
- Cavities:6 per pan
- Pan dimensions:12.5 x 8.5 x 3 inches
- Weight:1.6 pounds
- Shape:Round
- Care:Hand wash only
Our verdict“Choose Bellemain if you want stainless-steel pans for both donuts and bagels and accept hand washing and six cavities per pan.”
KASHME 3-Inch Silicone Donut Pan with Metal Frame (2 pcs)
The KASHME set gives you 12 donut cavities in two compact pans, with 3-inch rings that sit between Vnray’s larger 3.5-inch molds and HONGBAKE’s 2.8-inch cavities. Its metal-reinforced frames make the silicone easier to carry than an unsupported flexible mold, while the lightweight 8.32-ounce set is easier to store and handle than the 1.7-pound Chefmade pan. That lightness comes with a clear size tradeoff: these are smaller donuts, not full-size bakery-style rings. A light spray of oil is recommended for release, so the nonstick surface does not remove every preparation step. The listed temperature range spans -40°F to 446°F, and the product description includes uses beyond baking, but I’d select it chiefly for compact batch baking and framed silicone convenience.
Pros:- Two pans provide 12 total cavities.
- Metal-reinforced frames support handling and transfer.
- Lightweight 8.32-ounce set is easier to store and lift than the Chefmade pan.
- BPA-free silicone is rated from -40°F to 446°F.
Cons:- The 3-inch cavities make smaller donuts than Vnray’s 3.5-inch molds.
- A light spray of oil is recommended for release.
- Flexible silicone does not have the firm feel of carbon-steel pans.
Best for: Small-kitchen bakers who want two lightweight, framed silicone pans for batches of smaller 3-inch donuts.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want larger donuts, a rigid all-metal baking surface, or to avoid oiling silicone cavities.
- Brand:KASHME
- Material:BPA-free silicone with metal frame
- Number of pans:2
- Cavities:6 per pan; 12 total
- Pan dimensions:11.4 x 7.25 x 0.9 inches
- Cavity diameter:3 inches
- Weight:8.32 ounces
- Temperature range:-40°F to 446°F
Our verdict“Pick KASHME for compact storage and easy-to-carry silicone pans if 3-inch donuts suit your batch plans.”
Walfos Silicone Nonstick Donut Pan Set, 3-Piece
The Walfos set is the flexible pick for bakers who want donut molds that can also move between the oven, microwave, and freezer. Its three silicone molds release baked rings without a rigid metal pan, and the material is dishwasher safe for easier cleanup. Compared with the Bake Choice carbon steel pan, Walfos is easier to store and offers more temperature-range versatility, but the Bake Choice pan should feel steadier when filled and placed in the oven. Each mold is only 3 inches across, so these suit smaller donuts rather than oversized bakery-style rings. The instructions also recommend oiling before baking, which means the nonstick surface may not remove every step from preparation. Choose this set for flexibility, not maximum batch output or the most rigid support.
Pros:- Three flexible silicone molds release baked goods without a chemical nonstick coating
- Microwave- and freezer-safe design adds uses beyond oven baking
- Dishwasher-safe care simplifies cleanup
- Flexible molds are easier to store than rigid metal pans
Cons:- The 3-inch mold diameter may be too small for larger donuts
- Instructions recommend spraying with oil before use
- Flexible molds offer less support than rigid carbon steel pans when filled
Best for: Home bakers who want small donut molds that can also be used in the microwave or freezer and stored without a rigid pan taking up much space
Not ideal for: Bakers who want larger donuts or need a firm, easy-to-handle pan when transferring filled molds to the oven
- Material:Food-grade silicone
- Set size:3 molds
- Mold diameter:3 inches
- Dimensions:7 × 10 × 1 inches
- Temperature range:-40°F to 500°F
- Care:Dishwasher safe
- Special features:Microwave safe, freezer safe, flexible
Our verdict“Pick Walfos if flexible, multi-use silicone molds matter more to you than larger donuts or rigid oven handling.”
Bake Choice 6-Cavity Carbon Steel Donut Pan, 12.5 x 8.5 Inches
For a first donut pan, the Bake Choice keeps the format simple: six cavities, rigid carbon steel, and a food-safe nonstick coating. Its firm construction gives the pan a steadier feel when filled than the Walfos silicone molds, which can be more flexible to handle. The 3.25-inch cavities also offer a little more room than Walfos’s 3-inch molds, though they still limit donut size compared with larger-format baking options. This pan can also make ring cakes and bagels, so it has use beyond a single recipe. The main compromise is care: although it is listed as dishwasher safe, the instructions say to hand wash, so I would not choose it for fully hands-off cleanup. It suits occasional batches better than high-volume baking.
Pros:- Rigid carbon steel construction helps keep the pan steady when filled
- Food-safe nonstick coating supports easier release
- Six cavities make a manageable batch for beginners
- Can also be used for ring cakes and bagels
Cons:- Hand washing is specified in the care instructions despite the dishwasher-safe listing
- Six-cavity capacity is limited for larger batches
- Cavity dimensions restrict the size of donuts
Best for: New donut bakers who want one rigid, straightforward pan for small batches and occasional ring cakes or bagels
Not ideal for: Large households or frequent batch bakers who need more than six cavities at a time, or shoppers who require unambiguous dishwasher-safe care
- Material:Carbon steel
- Capacity:6 cavities
- Pan dimensions:12.5 × 8.5 inches
- Cavity inner dimensions:3.25 × 3.25 inches
- Coating:Food-safe nonstick
- Oven safe:Yes
- Care instructions:Hand wash
Our verdict“Choose Bake Choice for a steady, beginner-friendly six-donut pan if hand washing and modest batch size suit your routine.”
LYNCHAOXAN 2-Pack Nonstick Carbon Steel Donut Pan Set (24 Cavities)
When batch size drives the choice, this set leads the group: its two 12-cavity pans can bake up to 24 donuts at once, far more than the six-cavity Bake Choice or the YOVLOSIN two-pan set’s 12-donut total. Heavy-duty carbon steel is intended to distribute heat evenly and resist warping, while the nonstick coating supports release from the ring-shaped wells. The tradeoff is a substantial footprint: each pan measures 13.8 × 10.6 inches, so fitting both in an oven may be difficult. Hand washing is also recommended to preserve the coating, making cleanup less convenient than a dishwasher-safe option such as Walfos. This is the batch-production choice for family gatherings or repeated baking, not the best fit for a small oven or a baker who usually makes only a few donuts.
Pros:- Two pans provide 24 cavities for high-volume baking
- Heavy-duty carbon steel is designed for even heat distribution and warp resistance
- Nonstick coating supports easier donut release
- Oven safe up to 450°F
Cons:- The large pans may take up significant oven and storage space
- Hand washing is recommended to protect the nonstick coating
- The high cavity count may be excessive for occasional small batches
Best for: Families, party hosts, and frequent bakers who want to produce up to 24 donuts in one oven round
Not ideal for: Bakers with limited oven or cabinet space, or anyone who prioritizes dishwasher cleanup and small batches
- Material:Carbon steel
- Quantity:2 pans
- Total cavities:24
- Cavities per pan:12
- Dimensions:13.8 × 10.6 × 1.5 inches
- Maximum temperature:450°F
- Care instructions:Hand wash recommended
Our verdict“Choose this set when baking 24 donuts per round matters more than compact storage or dishwasher convenience.”
YOVLOSIN 2-Pack Nonstick Donut Baking Pans, 6-Cavity, Black
The YOVLOSIN set splits the difference between a single six-cavity pan and the larger 24-cavity LYNCHAOXAN set: two pans make 12 donuts per round, and the pair can be stacked for more compact storage. Each pan’s six 2.8-inch-deep cavities are designed for fuller, softer donuts, while the thicker carbon steel is intended to resist warping and bake evenly. Its stated 450°F limit matches the LYNCHAOXAN and Yumatouch pans, but the smaller total capacity makes it less suited to large gatherings. The PTFE/PFOA-free coating supports release without those listed compounds, though the product data does not specify a cleaning method. These pans make the most sense for bakers who want two manageable pans and a storage-friendly stack, rather than maximum output.
Pros:- Two pans provide a combined capacity of 12 donuts
- Stackable design helps save cabinet space
- Deep 2.8-inch cavities are intended to make full, soft donuts
- PTFE/PFOA-free nonstick coating supports easy release
Cons:- Six cavities per pan mean less output than the 12-cavity pans in the lineup
- The 2.8-inch cavity size limits donut diameter
- Care instructions are not specified in the provided product data
Best for: Home bakers who want two six-donut pans that stack neatly and produce fuller, small-format donuts
Not ideal for: Party bakers seeking the largest output per round, or shoppers who need a stated dishwasher-safe care option
- Material:Carbon steel
- Pack quantity:2 pans
- Cavities per pan:6
- Cavity diameter:2.8 inches
- Dimensions:11 × 7.5 × 1.18 inches
- Oven-safe temperature:450°F
- Nonstick coating:PTFE/PFOA free
Our verdict“Pick YOVLOSIN for stackable storage and two moderate batches, not for the highest capacity.”
Yumatouch 12-Cavity Nonstick Carbon Steel Donut Baking Pan
The Yumatouch packs 12 cavities into one pan, making it a practical choice for a full batch without storing a two-pan set. That gives it twice the cavity count of the Bake Choice, while the LYNCHAOXAN set still wins for total output with two 12-cavity pans. Its 2.75-inch wells are a little smaller than Bake Choice’s 3.25-inch cavities, so this pan favors standard or smaller donuts over larger rings. Carbon steel and a reinforced nonstick coating aim to support even baking and easier release with less oil, but hand washing is required for care. At 14 × 10.2 inches, it also needs a reasonably spacious oven and cabinet shelf. Choose it when one-pan capacity matters more than larger cavities or dishwasher cleanup.
Pros:- One pan holds 12 donuts, exceeding the six-cavity Bake Choice
- Reinforced nonstick coating is designed for release with less oil
- Carbon steel construction is described as resistant to scratches and warping
- Oven safe up to 450°F
Cons:- Hand washing is required to maintain the coating
- The 2.75-inch cavities limit donut size
- The 14 × 10.2-inch footprint may not suit compact ovens or storage
Best for: Families and home bakers who want a 12-donut batch from one pan rather than managing a multi-pan set
Not ideal for: Bakers who want oversized donuts, have limited oven space, or prefer dishwasher-safe bakeware
- Material:Carbon steel
- Cavity count:12
- Cavity diameter:2.75 inches
- Product dimensions:14 × 10.2 × 1 inches
- Item weight:0.87 kg
- Maximum temperature:450°F
- Care instructions:Hand wash
Our verdict“Choose Yumatouch for a high-capacity single pan if its smaller cavities and hand-wash care fit your baking routine.”
Wilton Gold Non-Stick Donut Pan Set – Made Without PFAS (2-Piece)
The Wilton Gold set suits bakers who want two pans for back-to-back batches without moving batter between a single tray. Its six wells per pan make a dozen donuts across the set, while the PFAS-free nonstick coating supports release without relying on PFAS. Compared with the single-pan USA Pan Bakeware 6-Well, Wilton offers more total capacity in the box; the USA Pan instead emphasizes heavy-gauge construction and a corrugated baking surface. Wilton’s extended handles add a practical grip, though two stainless-steel pans can feel heavy, and each tray still holds only six donuts. The set is a stronger fit for repeat batches than for anyone seeking a one-tray, high-capacity bake. Dishwasher-safe care is convenient, but the pans take up more storage space than a single mold.
Pros:- Two six-cavity pans provide capacity for a dozen donuts across the set.
- PFAS-free nonstick coating supports easier release.
- Stainless-steel construction is described as scratch-resistant and resistant to warping.
- Extended handles and dishwasher-safe care add convenience.
Cons:- Each pan holds only six donuts, so larger batches require multiple trays or rounds.
- The stainless-steel pans may be heavy to handle.
- A two-pan set requires more storage room than a single pan.
Best for: Home bakers who want two PFAS-free pans to bake a dozen standard donuts across consecutive or simultaneous batches.
Not ideal for: Bakers short on cabinet space or anyone who needs more than six donuts from one pan without running another batch.
- Brand:Wilton
- Model number:191002506
- Material:Stainless steel
- Pan count:2
- Cavities per pan:6
- Coating:PFAS-free nonstick
- Care:Dishwasher safe
Our verdict“Choose the Wilton set if you want two PFAS-free, dishwasher-safe pans for repeat batches and can accommodate their weight and storage needs.”
HAPPIELS 12-Well Nonstick Donut Pan
When filling a dozen wells in one go matters more than having a second pan, the HAPPIELS 12-well pan offers a straightforward alternative to the six-cavity Wilton Gold set. Its high-carbon-steel construction is intended to spread heat evenly, and the 450°F oven limit leaves room for many standard donut recipes. At 1.1 pounds, it is also lighter than the two-pound NutriChef two-pack listed here, though NutriChef gives you two separate six-cavity pans for greater batch flexibility. HAPPIELS trades dishwasher convenience for its larger single-tray capacity: it must be hand washed, and aerosol cooking sprays should be avoided. The coating is listed as free of PFOA, PFOS, and BPA, but that should not be read as a claim that it is free of every coating chemical.
Pros:- Twelve wells allow a full dozen donuts in one pan.
- High-carbon steel is intended to distribute heat evenly.
- Listed as free of PFOA, PFOS, and BPA.
- Oven safe up to 450°F.
Cons:- Hand washing is required.
- Aerosol cooking sprays should be avoided.
- A single tray offers less flexibility for separating batches than a two-pan set.
Best for: Bakers who want to fill a dozen donut cavities in one batch from a single, relatively lightweight tray.
Not ideal for: People who rely on dishwasher cleanup, prefer two separate pans for staggered baking, or use aerosol cooking spray.
- Brand:HAPPIELS
- Material:High-carbon steel
- Capacity:12 donuts
- Dimensions:13.75 × 10.75 × 0.8 inches
- Weight:1.1 pounds
- Maximum oven temperature:450°F
- Care:Hand wash
- Coating:Nonstick; listed as free of PFOA, PFOS, and BPA
Our verdict“Pick HAPPIELS if one-pan capacity for a dozen donuts outweighs hand washing and the need to avoid aerosol spray.”
Large Silicone Donut Pan for Baking – 9 Cavity Non-Stick Food Mold
The FUNLAVIE silicone mold is the flexible choice for bakers who want one pan to move between oven, microwave, freezer, and dishwasher. Its nine 3-inch cavities hold more than the six-well USA Pan Bakeware, while the USA Pan’s rigid aluminized steel body gives it a sturdier shape when filling and moving the tray. FUNLAVIE’s flexibility helps with storage and releasing baked goods, but it can also make the filled mold awkward to lift; setting it on a firm baking sheet before filling is a sensible workaround. It is rated to 450°F, so it is not for broiling or higher-heat recipes. The mold can also shape bagels or frozen treats, making it more versatile than a dedicated metal pan, though the silicone format may not suit buyers who prioritize rigid handling.
Pros:- Nine 3-inch cavities provide more capacity than a six-well pan.
- BPA-free silicone is listed as oven, microwave, freezer, and dishwasher safe.
- Flexible construction can simplify storage and release.
- Can also be used for bagels or frozen treats.
Cons:- The flexible mold can be awkward to lift when filled.
- Maximum heat resistance is 450°F, and it is not suitable for broiling.
- Its roughly 11-inch footprint may take up noticeable storage space.
Best for: Families and multi-use bakers who want nine donut molds plus microwave, freezer, and dishwasher flexibility.
Not ideal for: Bakers who want a rigid tray that stays firm when filled, or who need to use broiler heat or temperatures above 450°F.
- Brand:FUNLAVIE
- Material:BPA-free food-grade silicone
- Number of cavities:9
- Cavity diameter:3 inches
- Dimensions:11.1 × 11.2 × 1.1 inches
- Maximum heat resistance:450°F
- Appliance compatibility:Oven, microwave, freezer, and dishwasher safe
- Weight:11.68 ounces
Our verdict“Choose FUNLAVIE if flexible, multi-appliance use matters more to you than the rigid handling of a metal donut pan.”
NutriChef Nonstick Donut Pan, 2 Pack – 6-Cavity Carbon Steel, Oven Safe up to 450°F
The NutriChef two-pack is a practical pick for bakers who want two rigid trays and a familiar six-donut layout on each. Carbon steel with a nonstick silicone coating gives this set a different balance from the FUNLAVIE silicone mold: NutriChef keeps its shape when handled, while FUNLAVIE is lighter and offers microwave and freezer use. Both options reach 450°F, but NutriChef is dishwasher safe and offers two pans for alternating batches. Its six-cavity limit per tray means a dozen donuts requires using both pans, unlike the single-pan HAPPIELS 12-well. The listed coating is free of PFOA, PFOS, and PTFE, but the product data warns that prolonged high-heat use can wear the nonstick surface. Buyers should also expect full-sized donut wells rather than specialty or smaller shapes.
Pros:- Two six-cavity pans allow parallel or alternating batches.
- Carbon steel is intended to distribute heat evenly and resist warping.
- Nonstick silicone coating supports release and is listed as free of PFOA, PFOS, and PTFE.
- Dishwasher safe and oven safe up to 450°F.
Cons:- Each pan holds only six donuts, unlike the single-tray HAPPIELS 12-well.
- The wells are designed for full-sized donuts, limiting smaller or specialty shapes.
- The nonstick coating may wear with prolonged high-heat use.
Best for: Home bakers who want two rigid carbon-steel pans for full-sized donuts and appreciate dishwasher-safe cleanup.
Not ideal for: Bakers who need a single tray to hold more than six donuts, want smaller or specialty shapes, or expect a coating suited to prolonged high-heat use.
- Material:Carbon steel with nonstick silicone coating
- Pack quantity:2
- Cavities per pan:6
- Dimensions:12.59 × 8.26 × 0.91 inches
- Weight:2 pounds
- Maximum oven temperature:450°F (230°C)
- Care:Dishwasher safe
- Coating exclusions:PFOA-, PFOS-, and PTFE-free
Our verdict“Choose NutriChef if you want two rigid, dishwasher-safe pans for standard full-sized donuts and can work within six wells per tray.”
USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Donut Pan, 6-Well
The USA Pan 6-well puts build and baking design ahead of batch size. Its heavy-gauge aluminized steel and corrugated surface are intended to support even heating and airflow, while the AMERICOAT Plus silicone coating is listed as free of PTFE, PFOA, and BPA. Compared with the two-pan NutriChef set, USA Pan gives you only one six-donut tray, but its commercial-grade construction and lifetime warranty may appeal to buyers who want a durable single pan rather than a matched pair. The tradeoff is care: hand washing takes more effort than NutriChef’s dishwasher-safe cleanup. Its roughly 15.75-inch width also calls for a check of cabinet and oven space. Choose it for a sturdy, deliberately designed tray, not for maximum batch capacity.
Pros:- Heavy-gauge aluminized steel is designed for even heat distribution and durability.
- Corrugated surface is intended to promote airflow and release.
- AMERICOAT Plus silicone coating is listed as free of PTFE, PFOA, and BPA.
- Includes a lifetime warranty.
Cons:- Six-well capacity is lower than the 12-well HAPPIELS pan.
- Hand washing is required.
- At 15.75 inches wide, it may be awkward for smaller ovens or storage areas.
Best for: Frequent home bakers who value a heavy-gauge single pan, a distinctive corrugated surface, and a lifetime warranty.
Not ideal for: Bakers who need a dozen donuts per tray, prefer dishwasher cleanup, or have limited oven and cabinet width.
- Brand:USA Pan
- Material:Aluminized steel
- Capacity:6 wells
- Well dimensions:3.5 × 3.375 × 0.875 inches
- Overall dimensions:11.25 × 15.75 × 1.25 inches
- Coating:AMERICOAT Plus silicone; PTFE-, PFOA-, and BPA-free
- Care:Hand wash
- Warranty:Lifetime
Our verdict“Pick USA Pan if durable construction and its corrugated design matter more than high capacity or dishwasher-safe care.”

How We Picked
I compared these 15 pans by the details that affect actual donut baking decisions: cavity count and set size, stated material and construction, handling support, coating or nonstick claims, and any clearly specified oven-use information. I gave more weight to options that communicate a useful distinction—such as a two-pan set, a metal frame for silicone, or a stated PFAS-free coating—than to products whose names offer few details for comparison. I also considered the practical effect of cavity size where stated, since three-inch and 3.5-inch molds point to different donut sizes.
The ranking favors versatility and decision clarity over capacity alone. Wilton leads as a balanced two-pan option with a clearly stated coating detail; the large-cavity LYNCHAOXAN set suits volume baking but is less flexible for small batches. Framed silicone pans rank ahead of unsupported silicone for buyers who value flexible release but need easier transfers. Single rigid pans and smaller paired sets remain useful for compact kitchens or modest batches, while a product with limited published details ranks lower because buyers have less information for comparing care and oven compatibility.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Donut Baking Pans
Before choosing a pan, match its format to how you bake, not just the number of cavities on the listing. Batch size, support, and storage affect the experience as much as material does, and a pan that suits occasional weekend baking may frustrate someone preparing donuts for a group. These factors can help narrow the options beyond the individual product comparisons.
Choose Capacity Around Your Usual Batch
A higher cavity count can reduce repeated oven loads, but it only helps if you can fill and handle that pan comfortably. Think about how many donuts you normally serve and whether your oven can fit the pan with room for airflow. Larger pans may also need more counter space for filling and cooling. A six-cavity pan can be a sensible fit for occasional baking or a smaller household, while a 12- or 24-cavity option makes more sense when you regularly bake for a group. Avoid choosing maximum capacity solely to save time if most batches will leave many wells unused.
Decide Between Rigid Metal and Flexible Silicone
Metal pans hold their shape during filling and transfer, which can make them easier to carry from counter to oven. Silicone flexes more readily and can help with releasing baked goods, but an unsupported mold can bend when it is full. A metal frame or placing the mold on a sheet pan can reduce that handling problem. Neither material removes the need to follow the maker’s care and temperature guidance. Choose based on which task you want to make easier—steady transport or flexible removal—rather than treating material as a guarantee of baking results.
Check Donut Size and Cavity Shape
Donut pans do not all produce the same portion size, and cavity dimensions can change how much batter each well needs. A three-inch cavity may suit snack-size donuts, while a larger mold can yield a more substantial portion. Compare dimensions when available, especially if you want consistent serving sizes or plan to use a particular recipe. A recipe written for one pan may overfill or underfill another, affecting shape and bake time. Start with the recipe’s suggested fill level and adjust in a small test batch before filling every cavity.
Read Coating and Oven Details Carefully
“Nonstick” is not a complete care specification: coating composition, oven limits, and cleaning directions can differ across pans. Look for explicit manufacturer guidance instead of assuming all coated metal pans tolerate the same heat or utensils. If a listing identifies a specific attribute, such as a stated PFAS-free coating or maximum oven temperature, compare that claim with your preferences and recipes. Use tools and cleaning methods that the manufacturer permits to protect the surface. When details are absent, check the product documentation before using high heat or putting the pan in a dishwasher.
Factor in Storage and Multiple-Pan Flexibility
Two pans can be useful even when their total cavity count matches a single larger pan: you can bake one while preparing another, or use only part of the set for a small batch. The tradeoff is more pieces to store and wash. A wide, high-capacity pan may be efficient in the oven but awkward in a crowded cupboard. Measure both oven clearance and storage space before buying, including room to grip the pan with oven mitts. Compact kitchens may benefit more from stackable, smaller pans than from the largest capacity on paper.
Plan for Batter Filling and Cleanup
Donut batter is easier to portion evenly when the pan can sit level and each cavity is accessible. A piping bag or a sturdy food-storage bag with a snipped corner can reduce spills, especially with narrow ring molds. Consider whether the pan’s shape leaves enough room to clean around the center post and outer rim. Flexible silicone can turn inside out more readily for access, while rigid pans keep their shape during scrubbing. Check care instructions before choosing a cleaning method, and avoid assuming that a nonstick label makes every pan dishwasher-safe.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a metal donut pan or a silicone donut pan a better choice for a first-time baker?
For a first pan, many buyers will find rigid metal easier to fill and move because it keeps its shape without extra support. Silicone can be appealing if flexible release is a priority, but a filled mold may be harder to carry unless it has a frame or rests on a baking sheet. Your choice should also reflect the care instructions and oven limits for the specific model. If you are unsure, choose the format you can transfer securely with oven mitts. A successful first batch depends more on steady filling and following a suitable recipe than on material alone.
Should I buy a 12-cavity pan or two six-cavity pans?
Choose 12 cavities when you want to bake a larger batch in one pan and your oven has enough usable space. Two six-cavity pans give you more control over small batches and can let you prepare one pan while another is baking. They may also fit more easily in an oven with limited rack dimensions, though that depends on the pans’ actual measurements. Check whether you can bake both pans at once without crowding the oven. If you often make different flavors in the same session, separate pans can be more useful than a single large tray.
Can I use my regular cake-donut recipe in any of these pans?
Many cake-donut batters can be adapted to ring molds, but cavity size and shape affect how much batter fits and how quickly the centers bake. Avoid filling wells to the rim; follow the recipe’s guidance or start with a conservative amount in one test batch. If the pan’s cavities are smaller than the ones assumed by the recipe, you may have batter left over. Check doneness by the recipe’s cues and adjust bake time rather than relying on the original timing alone. A piping bag can help portion batter more evenly around each ring.
Do I need to grease a pan labeled nonstick?
A nonstick claim does not always mean the maker recommends baking without preparation. Follow the instructions supplied with the specific pan, since guidance can vary by material and coating. Some recipes may also call for a light coating to support release, particularly when the pan is new or the batter is low in fat. Avoid using sprays or tools that the manufacturer advises against, as they may affect the surface. If release is uncertain, test one batch and let the donuts cool as directed before removing them.
What should I check before buying a pan when oven fit is uncertain?
Compare the pan’s outside dimensions with the usable width and depth of your oven rack, not just the oven’s advertised capacity. Leave space around the pan so heat can circulate and so you can grip it safely. For a silicone mold, include the footprint of any supporting baking sheet in your measurement. Also check the listed oven-temperature limit against the recipes you plan to make. When a listing does not provide dimensions or temperature guidance, consult the manufacturer’s product details before purchasing rather than guessing.
Conclusion
For most home bakers, I recommend the Wilton Gold Non-Stick Donut Pan Set as best overall for its two-pan format and clearly stated PFAS-free coating. The best value-style choice for higher-volume baking is the LYNCHAOXAN 24-cavity set, provided you have room for a large batch. For a more premium rigid-pan option, consider the USA Pan aluminized steel model if you prioritize a named metal construction over a multi-pan set. Beginners who want a straightforward, supported format may prefer a rigid six-cavity carbon-steel pan such as Bake Choice; for specific needs, KASHME suits buyers who want flexible silicone with metal-frame support, while the 12-cavity pans suit those seeking fewer oven loads. Pick by your usual batch, oven fit, and preferred handling style—not cavity count alone.















