Choosing the perfect peanut butter frosting can depend on whether you’re after a creamy, spreadable icing or a potent flavoring to enhance baked goods. Scott’s Cakes Homemade Old Fashion Peanut Butter Butter Cream offers a smooth, homemade feel ideal for decorating, while LorAnn Oils Super Strength Peanut Butter Flavoring provides a concentrated burst of peanut flavor perfect for infusions. Both options are distinct in purpose and tradeoffs, so understanding these differences can help you select the right product for your baking projects.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
- Homemade-style frostings like Scott’s Cakes deliver a creamy, spreadable texture but are limited in flavor options.
- Concentrated flavorings such as LorAnn‘s require precise measurement but offer intense peanut flavor without altering textures.
- The butter-based frosting is better suited for decorating and frosting cakes, whereas flavoring excels in infusing baked goods.
- Size and packaging matter: larger or multi-use options might be more economical for frequent bakers.
- Tradeoffs include flavor strength versus ease of use—choose based on whether you prefer convenience or control.
| Scott’s Cakes Homemade Old Fashion Peanut Butter Butter Cream Icing 1/2 Pound |  | Best Overall for Creamy, Spreadable Peanut Butter Frosting | Weight: 1/2 Pound | Packaging: Plastic container, boxed for shipping | Flavor: Peanut Butter | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| LorAnn Oils Super Strength Peanut Butter Flavoring for Candy Making |  | Best for Intense Peanut Flavor in Baking and Confections | Strength: Three to four times typical | Usage: ¼ to ½ teaspoon per recipe | Kosher: Yes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| peanut butter frosting | Usage | Weight | Packaging | Flavor |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scott’s Cakes Homemade Old Fas | Frosting, decorating | 1/2 Pound | Plastic container, boxed for shipping | Peanut Butter |
| LorAnn Oils Super Strength Pea | ¼ to ½ teaspoon per recipe | — | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Scott’s Cakes Homemade Old Fashion Peanut Butter Butter Cream Icing 1/2 Pound
This pick stands out for its authentic, homemade feel, thanks to real butter and a whipped texture that makes it easy to spread on cakes and cupcakes. Compared with flavorings, it offers a more traditional frosting experience, perfect for decorating and layering. However, its limited size and flavor options mean it may not be the best choice if you’re seeking versatility or bulk. It’s best for bakers who want a ready-to-use, delicious peanut butter frosting that mimics homemade icing.
Pros:- Made with real butter and whipped for a smooth, creamy texture
- Squeezable and easy to spread or decorate
- Packaged securely for shipping and handling
Cons:- Limited flavor options and size
- Not suitable for recipes requiring a strong peanut flavor
Best for: Decorating cakes, cupcakes, and treats that benefit from a smooth, creamy frosting
Not ideal for: Recipes requiring intense peanut flavor or infusions where a standalone flavoring is needed
- Weight:1/2 Pound
- Packaging:Plastic container, boxed for shipping
- Flavor:Peanut Butter
- Texture:Smooth, whipped
- Made With:Real butter
- Usage:Frosting, decorating
Our verdict“A reliable, homemade-style peanut butter frosting ideal for decorating and spreading, but less suited for flavor infusions.”
LorAnn Oils Super Strength Peanut Butter Flavoring for Candy Making
This flavoring makes a strong impression with its high potency—three to four times more concentrated than typical extracts. Compared to the buttercream, it requires careful measurement but delivers a powerful peanut flavor that can elevate candies, cookies, and ice cream. It’s perfect for bakers who want to infuse recipes without altering textures or adding extra ingredients. The main tradeoff is that, if mismeasured, the flavor can become overwhelming or imbalanced, so precision is key.
Pros:- Highly concentrated, economical to use
- Versatile for many baking and candy recipes
- Kosher and gluten-free
Cons:- Requires precise measurement to avoid overpowering flavor
- Limited to flavoring, not a standalone frosting
Best for: Enhancing baked goods and confections with a robust peanut flavor
Not ideal for: Direct frosting applications or recipes where a creamy texture is preferred over flavoring
- Strength:Three to four times typical
- Usage:¼ to ½ teaspoon per recipe
- Kosher:Yes
- Gluten-Free:Yes
- Made In:USA
- Size:1 dram (approximate)
Our verdict“An excellent choice for flavor infusions that require a strong peanut taste, especially in candies and baked goods, but not for standalone frosting applications.”
How We Picked
In selecting these products, I focused on their core roles in peanut butter frosting applications—whether as a ready-to-spread icing or a flavor enhancer. I prioritized products with clear specifications, positive user feedback, and versatility. Compatibility with typical baking needs, ease of use, and potential tradeoffs were central to the evaluation. Price and packaging also played a role to ensure each product offers good value for its specific purpose.
| peanut butter frosting | Usage |
|---|---|
| Scott’s Cakes Homemade Old Fas | Frosting, decorating |
| LorAnn Oils Super Strength Pea | ¼ to ½ teaspoon per recipe |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Peanut Butter Frosting
When choosing peanut butter frosting products, it’s essential to consider your primary use—whether you want a ready-to-spread icing or a flavoring to boost baked goods. Factors like flavor strength, texture, ease of use, and recipe compatibility will influence your choice. Understanding these elements helps ensure you pick a product that aligns with your baking goals, budget, and skill level.
Type of Product
If you’re looking for a ready-made frosting that you can spread directly on cakes and cupcakes, a buttercream-style product like Scott’s Cakes offers convenience and a classic texture. Conversely, if you want to enhance recipes with a peanut flavor without changing the texture, a concentrated flavoring like LorAnn’s is more suitable.
Flavor Intensity
Consider how strong you want the peanut flavor to be. Buttercream frostings will have a mild, creamy peanut taste, ideal for decorating. Flavorings are much more potent, providing an intense peanut punch that can be used sparingly in recipes for a balanced result.
Ease of Use
Pre-made frostings are straightforward—simply spread and decorate. Flavorings require careful measurement; too much can overpower your recipe, while too little might not deliver enough flavor. Think about your comfort level with measuring and experimenting when choosing.
Size and Packaging
For frequent bakers, larger sizes or multi-use packaging might provide better value. Smaller containers are ideal for occasional use or testing new recipes. Packaged securely, these products should also be easy to handle and store.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use peanut butter flavoring directly as frosting?
While peanut butter flavoring like LorAnn’s is highly concentrated and can be added to frosting recipes to boost flavor, it isn’t designed as a standalone frosting. To create a spreadable frosting, you’ll need to mix it with ingredients like butter, sugar, or cream to achieve the desired consistency and sweetness.
How do I measure concentrated flavorings to avoid overpowering my recipe?
It’s best to start with a small amount—about ¼ teaspoon per recipe—and taste as you go. Since these flavorings are much stronger than extracts, careful measurement prevents an overly intense flavor. Using measuring spoons or droppers can help ensure accuracy and consistency.
Is a buttercream frosting better than using flavoring for peanut flavor?
This depends on your goal. Buttercream frosting like Scott’s Cakes provides a creamy, spreadable base with a mild peanut flavor, suitable for decorating. Flavorings, on the other hand, are better when you want a concentrated punch of peanut flavor to mix into baked goods or fillings without affecting texture.
Can I combine these products for a better result?
Yes, many bakers use flavorings like LorAnn’s to infuse homemade buttercream or other frostings, blending the best of both worlds—creamy texture and intense flavor. Just remember to measure carefully to avoid overpowering the frosting or recipe.
Are these products suitable for people with dietary restrictions?
Both products have options for those with specific dietary needs; LorAnn’s flavoring is gluten-free and kosher, making it suitable for many restrictions. The buttercream frosting is made with real butter, so those with dairy sensitivities should avoid it. Always check packaging for allergen information and consider your dietary requirements before purchasing.
Conclusion
If you primarily want a ready-to-use peanut butter frosting for decorating, the buttercream option from Scott’s Cakes is ideal. It offers a smooth, homemade taste with minimal effort, perfect for cake decorating enthusiasts. For bakers seeking to infuse a strong peanut flavor into various recipes—candies, cookies, or ice cream—LorAnn’s flavoring is the best choice, provided they are comfortable measuring small quantities. Both products have their roles, and your choice depends on whether you prioritize ease of use or flavor intensity.
NFL season / tailgating Picks
team gear
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
